I'm still trying to organize my ideas.....I had not too much time to listen everything in details as I would like, but pretty much I tried for a good period of time, with a few tracks I'm really used to and I know very well, the new Qualia, "the King" R-10, and tried also but not for long time, but time enough to conclude my preferences, the PS-1, HP-1000, HD650 + Zu Mobious, and K-1000, pretty much a little of everything. I hate to post impressions based on a meeting, in which you've tried the different setups only for a few minutes, but anyway we have to say something, and as you are asking for it....here I go, more to come....I can't talk too much of what I liked and why I liked it, I need more time to form a more detailed opinion, but for sure I know what I didn't like, and what is not my cup of tea at all….
Take my comments as a grain of salt, and please do not take anything personal. All the members there were extremely nice, and I felt really comfortable there, and honestly I liked all of the members in that room, and I have to thank everybody for making this little session possible, (special mention to Tom, you guys have to agree with me, that carrying 7 boxes or gear, just for alistening session of an hour or two, is not an easy task, including two of the size of a computer monitor)…..I felt like in a big family, and I do not want any member to feel bad, or uncomfortable with any of my posts, being the owners of this gear I will mention. Regarding that meeting, it was a pleasant experience for me, and I do not want to ruin that pleasure with any hard feeling later…..OK? Anyway preferences is all about....and what is good for me, for others may not, and in this case, nobody is wrong, just that we all have different tastes…period...and as usual read my disclaimer, all is IMO, to my ears...etc.....
IMHO, and IMHE the king of the day was the legendary R-10...in any setup I tried it, it was really euphonic and seductive, extremely musical....maybe all the amps there were good for it, but in all cases it really shined, whomever have said, that the R-10 is lacking on the bass dpt, has never heard the R-10 in a good setup…period….I even feel it with the same bass amount as my CD3000. IME it is ike a CD3000 on steroids, a little better on eveything, but similar signature (just a quick note before I forgot, the Supra there had a hum, whomever the owner is, please check that, don't know if the rest of the members noticed that, but my brother and me, both, noticed it, and it was noticeable with the R-10 and with the CD3000)……
About the other tube monsters in the room, and far from trying to make anybody feel bad, I'm trying to make myself feel comfortable. And I know that is not right to blow my own horn, but I don't think I will get any other blow….LOL….So it's me or nobody, I do not recall, many members having heard seriously the two more humble setups, the PPA and the Solo, so I will post my own impressions, about my own setup, kind of horrible, eh???.....(Of course the main goal on that meeting was to hear the Qualia, not a PPA or a Solo amp)
Call this meet impressions, you know what I mean, it was my first, and I was like trying to hear everything at the same time, OK?
Well, honestly I was expecting to be absolutely blown away by the Cary, Maestro, modded Melos, or the new Supra, given the difference in price tag, and the praises here in headfi, but sorry guys, today, this didn't happen at all. They are all very good and darn fine amp, with a wonderful sound, but practically talking, and given the price difference, I think I will keep the PPA forever, to my ears, there was nothing that I noticed I was missing with that humble PPA, while I was listening to any of these "Giants" killers there, even while them, IIRC, were hooked to a very good external DAC, while the PPA was hooked directly to the SCD-XA9000ES, so maybe with a better source, my opinion will be even more favorable toward the PPA (IIRC the Solo was using an external DAC as well) Don't take me wrong, but my cloth ears were not able to find anything in the sound, that justified spending that huge difference in price, over what I paid for my humble PPA, on any of them. Again, I can be wrong, and maybe in a more extended listening session probably my opinion will be different…and it will be only that, at the end, my opinion, OK? I know that probably I may need more time, and a more extended listening period of time, but the PPA sounded to me, in that short comparison, at the same level of all of the amps in that room, again take this comment as a grain of salt (I hate to say that, as it is my amp, and I love it, but the love is not what is talking now, believe me) and for sure I need more time for a better and more complete evaluation of all of them…
BTW the Solo really impressed me, I was expecting a more humble amp, the sound is really nice, at the level of any other more expensive amp, even it was able to drive the K-1000 to a decent level, pretty good…..two thumbs up for Pinky….good job man...
I heard for a few minutes the SR-71, IMO very clear, airy, but too thin sounding, again, you may say that I'm used to the bass boost, but the rest of the amps sounded OK regarding that area to me, and none of them has bassboost, so IMO, this was not the reason. OTOH, comparing this tiny amp, to what was inside that room, the result is pretty obvious to me, at the end it is just an small portable amp, but not my cup of tea at all.
Well now the Qualia our main concern and the pricipal topic here (at least for me)…well honestly as Tom wisely said, the highs are there, the mids are there, the lows are there, but too perfect to be true, and to be good, IMO, there is nothing seductive on it, that screams "buy me", at least not hooked ot any of those setups…...OTOH I don't know if it was only my impression, but I felt it sounded hollow, like listening to the music inside a cave, I hear like reflections, resonances, echoes, I don't know the exact term for that…and it is extremelly weird, because people complained that the CD3000 sounded like that, and I have never noticed that effect before, and the Qualia that is a completelly open back headphone by nature, to my ears had this problem. I don't know but it seems that I had spent too much time with closed cans, and being it an open can, makes the presentation a little different, honestly I prefer the R-10 by a good margin….the construction is Ok to me, but I would like more freedom for adjustments in the headband, and the cable is very similar to the one on the CD3000, at least to the look and touch…
The PS-1 and HP-1000 IMO, and according to my short audition of them, sounded in comparison to the Qualia, R-10, CD3000, and K-1000, dull and bass bloated to my cloth ears, call me nuts if you want….LOL…but I would choose any of the prior mentioned ones over these two Grados any day…...I know that some of you guys love those headphones, and will swear on them, but IMO too heavy (at least the PS-1) and too uncomfortable, and I didn't like the sound of them a little bit. Call them neutral, balanced, natural, whatever you want, but what I heard today, both hooked on a Carlo's modded Melos, PPA, and some other amps, didn't sound natural to me at all, neither…OTOH, I felt a lot more natural, and a lot more musical, the R-10.....Thanks Tom for making my dream possible...LOL...
HD650+Zu Mobious…same impression as I had before of the HD600, I was expecting a huge change with this new HD650, and honestly, IMO the HD650 is an HD600 with a little better bass extension, but I felt it sort of rolled off at the end in both ways, not my cup of tea neither at all…
One thing I must admit today is that I'm pretty satisfied with my humble setup now, I heard some other very good setups, and I noticed that mine is not that bad in comparison, so in the near future, as my budget is not so generous, I will not look for anything else (R-10 appart...LOL...
).