Early Bird backer checking in. Let me bore you with a story:
This Christmas I bought my dad some $350 Enchroma glasses, which help people with red/green color confusion to see those colors more distinctly. The cones in our eyes have evolved to pick up specific wavelengths for each color, and those with typical red/green color confusion have red cones and green cones tuned to too similar a wavelength, producing a sort of muddy yellow-gray brightness. Enchroma glasses have diffraction gratings which bend the normal red or green spectra into ranges more perceptible to 'mutated' eyes, and after the brain begins to understand how to parse this new information, the effect is revelatory.
Driving home from the restaurant where I gave the glasses to him, we reached an intersection and he said, "Now I understand why they use red as the color to stop!"
A day later, I called him around 5:30 in the afternoon to say that it would be worth stepping outside with the glasses on. "OK. I'll call you back," he said, and then a few minutes later: "I watched the sunset. I... it was a thousand percent better than any other sunset I've seen."
To have never before known the roses and peaches and purples and oranges and magentas of a good sunset... Like I said, the effect is revelatory.
And wouldn't it be awesome if the next thing I said was that this is what the nuraphone is like? I think that would be awesome. Let me bore you some more:
Credentials, if they're worth anything: I've been a member, albeit a quiet one, of head-fi for a decade. In my 30s, an audiologist commended me for still having the hearing of someone in their 20s. Granting that I've never stepped up to the highest of the high end, and have been comfortably mid-fi for a while with a Sony MA-900 and geekOut, I'll admit that I'm reluctant to step up to the higher end because I want to be able to keep slumming it with lossy youtube and spotify and my 20 years of MP3s from all over the place, rather than have to contort my tastes to Chesky Records et al, demanding lossless everything. I love being able to bounce around from
an orchestral game music cover to
club music that I heard in a YouTube Red show to
sweetly shimmering solo mostly-acoustic work to
music from Saharan cell phones, and on and on. For whatever reason or reasons, I haven't been able to pass Tidal's lossless vs lossy test on any hardware that I own (MA-900, HE-4XX, humble VE Monk+ [edit: and now TH-X00 PH and Kannon]), but that doesn't seem to stop me from being able to feel like music is playing
through me. I fsck with that ASMR shiz, that Frisson shiz, that synesthesia shiz. Hit me right, and I sparkle.
Alright? I bring that up just so you have an idea of how picky I am, what I'm getting out of this whole music thing, and where I am in the summit-fi journey (~if you want to listen to your music through your hardware, turn to page 42; if you want to listen to your hardware through your music, turn to page 86~ etc).
On to the nuraphone:
I love this company. They're so earnest and committed. As a startup, they've gone to lengths to ensure that no corners were cut, snapped, or bent out of shape along the way. Despite having to drag out their final shipping date by like a whole year or whatever, the truth is that this happens routinely to Kickstarter projects, so I can't even get miffed about that. Their support staff have been friendly and reasonably prompt, albeit a touch rushed or ESL-seeming at least once.
The case is neat, though I assume that its matte texture will accumulate scuffs and scratches if I were to really put it through some paces. The cables feel nice, and are a proper length. The headphones feel nice in the hand, and although they're reasonably heavy, they don't really feel heavy on my head. And everything sincerely looks good, in my opinion.
The inside of each headphone cup has a little nubby protrusion, meant to rest against your ear canal. Within the nibs are the innermost driver, which will handle all of the highs while the outermost drivers handle most lows. The nibs also help channel the otoacoustic emission detector, which is how they measure your personal hearing curve, sorta. I guess. Or try to, at least. Let it be said that some people find the nibs unoffensive, and some people are perpetually bothered by them. Customer service will cheerfully tell you that the soft silicone will warm up and mold to the shape of your ear in time, even if it never really does. In my case, my left ear is fine but my right ear is bothered enough to start hurting after a while.
You put the headphones on, and a text-to-speech voice says "Welcome back, [your name]." The novelty of that wore off within a couple of wearings. And when I had someone else try them on, it welcomed her back with my name. Oops?
You pair the 'phones via bluetooth, and try to access them with the nuraphone app. It asks for a code which you get by signing up online, then it puts you through the paces of calibrating your 'Personalized Sound'. Starts with ensuring that there is an adequate seal around your head, which it's somehow able to measure and show to you with an illustration of the headphone cups growing darker (better seal) or lighter (weaker seal). Then runs through some ~beedly-boop diddly-doop, beedly-boop diddly-doop~ cascading microtones as the otoacoustic emission sensor susses out the nuances of your inner ear.
When it's done, it tries to impress you by making much ado about switching from the 'Generic' un-EQ'd mode to your 'Personalized Sound'. There's hardly any way to speed through this process, so if you ever do it more than once, you have to patiently listen to the text-to-speech bot talk you through what you already know. I found a way to skip a screen, but it seemed less like a pro-strat and more like something that QA overlooked.
Golly I haven't started talking about the sound quality, have I. Over 1000 words so far, on a forum about quality sound, and I haven't told you much about the sound quality. Ha. Ha ha. Surely that's not a bad sign, right?
Let me try to give you some informed commentary on this really cool video that they uploaded a little while ago:
17s: "Okay. So now, I press this?" O_O "Wow. Whoa. Holy crap!"
24s: O,O "Oh! Haha!"
27s: "Oh, ****. That is
huge."
etc
Translation: The touch-sensitive buttons can be set to do things like on/off, or turn 'Immersion' on/off. They're probably being wowed by the 'Immersion' mode, which uses the outermost driver to produce... a type of bass that's bigger (bigger; please note that I did not say better) than most headphones, and certainly more than any headphone those people have ever experienced.
50s "The physical aspect is just completely unique. Like never, never with headphones have I had that sensation. It's really amazing."
Translation: The bass driver really can move enough to transduce some kinetic energy into your head, albeit while distorting the quality of the lower audio spectra. Maybe you want to feel 80Hz, but in my experience this also seems to mean that you're going to get a big bump of audible 80Hz as well. Will that start to interfere with your enjoyment of the music? It did for me, and I presumptuously presume that that sound engineer would agree after spending some critical listening time with it. And my bet is that if he tried a pair of Kannons, he'd rescind his "completely unique" endorsement along the way.
1:05 "When you listen to really amazing― you know, in a recording studio you're listening to a huge sound made by very expensive monitors... That's the only thing I can compare that to, really."
Translation: It's a closed headphone, thus lacking a broad soundstage, so 'huge' in this case mostly means 'putting your head too close to a speaker'. When you crank the "immersion" slider, it gets clippy and overbearing just like being too close to a big speaker. While the visceral impact is neat, you can't get that visceral impact without distorting the rest of the audible bass along with it.
1:20 "That's just amazing, switching from 'Generic', which I guess is 'headphones', to, uh, 'Personalized'..."
Translation: Please don't be suckered by this. 'Generic' mode is just their regular poorly-measuring meh drivers, which are not comparable to real head-fi quality headphones in the same price range. They sound like junk if they aren't EQ'd ("Personalised"), regardless of whether they're EQ'd ("Personalised") to your ears. It is as much a parlor trick as its being able to say "Welcome back, [your name]." (
Is THIS your card? No? Oh...)
1:44 "I've been sitting in the middle of the orchestra. It sounds the same."
Never having sat in the middle of an orchestra, I don't actually feel comfortable claiming or disclaiming much about that assertion. At most I can say that at CES one year, in the High End Audio rooms, I heard a system that made it sound like there was a man playing a guitar right there in front of me, even though there was a wall in front of me. He was there, clear as day, no matter how impossible that was. The nuraphones never ever evoked that in me.
1:51 "The brass, it's all, you know, super clear. Persussion... You can hear the timpani but it's not, sort-of, it's not distorted. Um. Yeah."
Does this timpani sound distorted to you?
It doesn't to me. So
~Um. Yeah.~ indeed. Maybe I'm too mid-fi or she's never listened to decent headphones in her life.
2:00 "You know what we were talking about before, with film music and eliciting physiological responses? How powerful that is? You're actually doing that with this set of headphones."
As a guy who just watched the last Star Wars in a "4D" theater with super cool motion chairs, but still thought, "This would've sounded better on the Tempe IMAX's sound system..." multiple times throughout the movie, I don't just know what he's talking about, I'm getting picky between various high-end theater sound systems. And I feel conflicted, because if you're talking about the rumbly bass compared to regular headphones then the answer is sure-I-guess-better-than-regular-headphones. But not much else about the sound feels very engaging to me.
2:18 "Fffffffunky in the front row! crap!"
3:08 "I am just coming, coming down from that, which was quite intense, actually. It was a display of speaker power, on my head."
AGAIN, sliding the 'Immersion' slider to the max just produces a really distorted and messy sound. You almost certainly won't want to listen to songs that way, whether critically or for enjoyment, and even movies will get obnoxious quickly. You'll want the physical rumble but not the distorted sound that comes with it.
3:22 "Wow, the bottom end is unreal. It's like standing in front of a Funktion 1 PA."
As I said before: "'huge' in this case mostly means 'putting your head too close to a speaker'. When you crank the "immersion" slider, it gets clippy and overbearing just like being too close to a big speaker."
3:38 "Probably are the best headphones anyone's gonna hear. So far."
Would that it were so.
Sparkly treble? No.
Spaciousness akin to an open-back? No.
Clean bass? No.
Delicate articulation? No
Evenness across all bands? No.
It's not a total hate-fest, I promise! They have a pretty nice attack in the higher frequencies, which can make drum snaps and clicky ASMR sounds stand out in the scene nicely. And when the visceral bass part works well, it is memorably better than most other headphones. And the isolation is remarkably good! Plus they're bluetooth and have a built-in microphone, neither of which I was expecting when I joined the Kickstarter.
I'm... digging for more positive things to say about their sound. But coming up snake-eyes.
Sadly, the nicest thing I can say is that I hope they weren't able to calibrate to my hearing correctly, and that I hope some other longtime head-fi'er, one with oodles of experience and more normally-shaped ears, comes along and says "I don't know what you're talking about! These are aktually the most clearest n sparkliest, most engagingestester headphones I've ever done heard! And somehow they don't sound closed even thogh they are! And the tactile bass doesn't really cause that audible bass to become distracting at all!" I could believe that they miscalibrated to my right ear, because it sincerely hurts due to improperly fitting ― but that doesn't explain why they feel so disengaging in general, even from the properly-fitting left ear. What it DOES explain is why the sound is lopsided. I didn't mention that, did I. The otoacoustic emission sensor measures near the eardrum but doesn't account for any of the outer ear. So even though it completes the calibration process, it keeps miscalibrating on me to be kinda 60/40 lopsided.
When I asked them if there was a way to adjust the EQ for each channel to manually correct for this, they said "We have worked very hard to develop a headphone that creates your Personalised Sound for you, and don't want the nuraphone to be subject to interference. EQ adjustment could potentially compromise the sound quality." Cool, thanks. So there's that, I guess. In myriad ways, I'm not their typical user.
Oh, almost forgot: In the present firmware they have a weird way of sliding their volume down to silence and then sliding it back up. If I skip ahead in a youtube video, or open a video on my harddrive, the sound doesn't just START, it quickly fades up from silence. Which is a small irritation, but worth noting.
So. Verdict on nuraphone:
Try before you buy, and be very critical of the parlor tricks.
My inner-ears don't need much correcting, but maybe yours do.
One of my outer ears doesn't play super well with their silicone nibs, but maybe yours do.
If I had to choose between the nuraphone and the $5 VE Monk+, I'd choose the Monk. (Ouch.)
The company is still really neat, and I feel disappointed that I can't be their ~NUMBA ONE FAN~ on head-fi.
I still want some closed-back headphones to complement and counterpoint my various open-backs, so now I'm on the Kannon waiting list.
______________________________________________
Edit, several months later:
I have since upgraded my daily-wear gear to a Fostex TH-X00 Purple Heart and a Taction Kannon. The Kannon's tactile feedback feels so much better, more nuanced, and more controlled to me than nura's 'immersion', and these days I feel sad at the idea of trying to watch movies or play video games without them. The PH on the other hand is the most musically fun, engaging, and pretty-darned-forgiving pair of headphones that I've tried yet; I did not realize that I could experience frisson so readily until I got my Purple Hearts.
Back in the realm of nuraphone: They have recently upgraded to "G2", or the second generation of nuraphone firmware and software. The software is prettier and offers more features ("factory reset" was impossible before, for example). Firmware has made the nura capable of using its built-in mics to generate Active Noise Cancellation on top of the already pretty amazing isolation that it previously provided, and now they have a 'Social Mode' which lets you hear ambient sounds without having to peel one of the 'phones off.
Doesn't seem to do anything to resolve my other issues, though. So my final verdict now is almost exactly the same as before, except that
"I still want some closed-back headphones to complement and counterpoint my various open-backs, so now I'm on the Kannon waiting list." is done and dusted.
I really wanted to love you, nura. We just can't be together.