Austrian Audio HI-X65 Vs Ultrasone Edition 11.
HI-X65 using tweaked version of oratorys eq. Edition 11 using no eq.
Lows.
The HI-X65 here has much less impact and rumble. Yet its faster and more separated. There are more details that you hear.
The Edition 11 has big low end. Alot of impact, not Fostex TH900/TH909 levels. But I prefer the presentation more on the Edition 11 as the S Logic actually works. It has this extremely surounding feel to the low end and the whole sound. More on that later. The low end is no where near as fast as the HI-X65, but this isnt a bad thing. Again, more on that later. Still, its not muddy, its very clean and behaves. When it needs to stop, it stops. Separation again is no where near the level of the HI-X65, but sub and mid bass still behave and keep eachother separated. The Edition 11 has more mid bass impact than sub bass rumble.
Mids.
The HI-X65 is more forward in its mid presentation. It's thinner, much more detailed, more clearer but not as full sounding as the Edition 11. You hear so so so much clarity and detail, you actually don't miss that slight lack of fullness. Because you can hear very minute details of guitar strums and plucks. Little things that add up to the whole experience. Are the mids very thin though, no. There still is a nice weight to them.
The Edition 11 has slightly recessed lower mids, and high mids get a touch of energy. Yet the overall mids are still clear and do not feel muddy or lacking. In what you sacrifice for sheer clarity and detail, you gain more fullness and weight. The vocals are not as upfront, but this helps with the staging. It's not a sound that makes you focus on every detail, all the clarity and every instrument. It makes you forget and just enjoy the music. Guitar though and acoustic. UGH such an amazing joy to listen too. Stop analysing the music. Just listen and enjoy it.
Treble.
The HI-X65 has more treble clarity, detail, extension. But with a similar sparkle of the Edition 11. Maybe it's a touch smoother. But I do mean a touch. Overall a much more detailed and clear presentation of treble.
The Edition 11 doesn't sound muted in the treble though. There is more than enough energy to keep things interesting and detailed. Extension is still very good. But on some songs, it can become just a touch and I mean a touch to energetic. It's less than the Arya or HD800/800s though. If you can handle that treble, the Edition 11 will be no problem for you. Usually this only happens on songs that have been mastered poorly. In a way, it shows the Edition 11 while very musical, it still is revealing of quality.
Now after treble. The rest is my fave part of the comparison.
Imaging.
I don't really have to say much as some of you have read about how I feel the HI-X65 does here when compared to the Avantone Planar. The HI-X65 does amazingly well here. It is extremely accurate and pinpoint but more. It strectches the boundaries and does some crazy scary things with its imaging. Very very good.
The Edition 11 though.... It's still a headphone that blows my mind till this very day. S Logic works!!! I always felt S Logic sucks and makes things sound extremely off with Ultrasone headphones that have that strange rectangular cup. On the circular cups, it was better. But the cups didn't feel deep enough and again. I could hear potential. But Ultrasone didn't hit the nail yet. So honestly, not many Ultrasone headphones really impressed me at all. They were way to overpriced and just yeah. Eh. The Edition 15 was alright... But wayyyy to overpriced. Way way way to overpriced. It was an instant no. But my my my, I'll never forget the first time I heard the Edition 11. It was love at first listen. But what was it that made me fall in love with them. S-LOGIC !!!!. Finally, after years, I understood it. The imaging on the Edition 11 is magical. If right up there with the HI-X65. But a bit different with how it presents music. I wouldn't say its as accurate. Not because it blurs music, but more like it enhances it. It's strange and tricky to describe. But, the HI-X65 has a more realistic sense of imaging. But the Edition 11 makes it more fun if that makes sense. More 3D. Still very very very good though. The forward imaging though is what gets me always. And at times, maybe slightly better than the HI-X65. So HI-X65 is more realistic. The Edition 11 is very very good but has this 3D effect. It's very unique.
Soundstage.
I'll do the same thing. Benchmark is Senn HD800. 110% in all directions.
Austrian Audio HI-X65.
Plays 70% left and right.
75% depth.
75% forward. 75% back.
70% height. And at times, surpasses all directions with an extra 10%.
Ultrasone Edition 11
Play 75% left and right.
???% Depth
80% forward. 75% back.
75% height. And at times, surpasses all directions with ???%.
At most. The Edition 11 has the larger soundstage in all directions. But what is the magic. It's the depth. The depth feels endless. The Arya and HD800/800s are deep feeling. But the Edition 11 feels even deeper at times. And such a unique presentation of the music. It's tricky to focus on whats going on because of how spacious and deep the sound can be. It varies alot between songs, some sound normal, some sound intimate then some just sound HUGE!!! Endless. And that's where it really takes my breath away. Sometimes in all directions it feels like it can spread further too. Doesn't happen always. Again, varries on the song. But it can happen. Now this soundstage with this insane 3D like imaging. It's a very unique listening experience. That I truly absolutely love. But it doesn't end yet..
Dynamics.
Now I do feel the HI-X65 does better with quiet passages. It gets the slightest sounds so clearly. Amazing dynamic range it has.
But the Edition 11 has this dynamic slam in the whole sound. It can go from sounding calm to suddenly intense in a second. It really grabs you by surprise. Add in the soundstage and imaging. It can do some wild things.
Again. Both are very different here. And its subjective on which you'd prefer. They both are very very good at what they do.
So the big question.
How does the HI-X65 stack up against a 999 Euro headphone that I feel could cost more due to its absolute awesome price to performance. I feel the HI-X65 does damn well. The Edition 11 is one hell of an amazing headphone. Especially for the price, I feel its a bargain. It's expensive yes but so damn worth it. The HI-X65 while extremely different tuning. Extremely different listening experience. It sure is damn amazing for even less. Loving them both