Quote:
Originally Posted by Nepenthe /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Their first, Asleep in the Back, opened to high praise and is a very cohesive and mature "debut" album. I'd say it is probably the best introduction to the band, if only for the fact that I'd recommend picking up everything and you can go chronologically if you start here.
|
That's the right answer. Kind of a mix of Radiohead and Peter Gabriel. The latter would be a great choice for Radiohead fans that like their adventurous and arty side, especially in the earlier PG days like III (or Melt as it's known nowadays). Sounds almost like a Best of Peter Gabriel when I listen to it today. Just a colossal record from the beginning "Intruder", built around a very cool Phil Collins drum track, to the beautiful and epic "Biko" closer, that strongly hinted at where he was headed next in his African-inspired world music and collaborations.
Quote:
These albums sound great on headphones, there is no unnecessary compression, etc. |
Wow, while the debut sounds pretty nice by modern pop standards, by the time that third CD hit the market, their sound had become pretty compressed and congested. Course, I guess so has Radiohead, though Godrich still manages to get a lushness to the sound. Regardless, Elbow is a good choice, and I do also like that third one, but after getting to know and love it, I can't say it has held up as well as the first. Just something more loveable about that debut.
Peter Gabriel and Pink Floyd and Mercury Rev and The Verve and Catherine Wheel, and a bunch more come to mind. But just to pick one, assuming most people probably have the classics by Gabriel and Floyd and the rest, I'd say
Chrome by Catherine Wheel. Rocks hard at times, great production, good lyric themes, but still has some of the Pink Floyd ethereal sound too. Their peak, for me, but the debut is a knockout too. Kind of went in a different direction after this, and I did follow, but became more and more disappointed with each successive record. Those first two are gems, though.
Or maybe Sunny Day Real Estate
How It Feels To Be Something On. Kind of a left-field comparison, but to me this record moves in that same Smith's style of emotional British guitar rock, with a mix of progressive elements.
Best one not mentioned so far but seemingly perfect for Radiohead and/or Pink Floyd fans: Spiritualized
Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating In Space.