- Joined
- Jun 4, 2014
- Posts
- 3,652
- Likes
- 2,927
Hi @james444, I found your track - it's available as a Master on Tidal. I listened to "Empty White House" through my V30 with the standard Tidal app to the XB10 in most stable (AAC) and best sound quality (aptX HD) modes using the balanced output to my SE846. I hear a distinct improvement with aptX HD, but not for the reasons I expected. Using the AAC codec I hear what sounds like the usual re-sampling artifacts at the bridges between the string instruments and the silence. It's pretty bad. AptX HD is better, but not consistent, and substitutes the nasty re-sampling artifacts for a consistent noise floor. I also tried the non-MQA version via the XB10 and the results sounded identical to my ears. Using single-ended output has a similar effect, but with a higher noise floor. Of course, plugging the SE846 directly into the V30, all these issues go away and it sounds great
I did the same tests with Focal Utopias (balanced and single-ended into the XB10) and then the AAC and AptX HD were much closer - I struggle to hear any re-sampling artifacts on higher-impedance/lower-sensitivity headphones.
Whatever weird things the XB10 is doing may be manifesting itself slightly differently in your headphones, but what I hear in AAC mode is the amp on the XB10 completely cuts out in those moments of silence, and then turns back on again when the music kicks in again. The clicks are quite audible at those points, so we're probably hearing the same effect.
I went back to my Samsung S8 (aptX support, but not aptX HD) and played the same track through the Tidal app on that. It sounded similar to that of the V30 at its best when using aptX HD - but overall the S8 was more consistent, so I'd have the say the S8 was the winner. (I have no option to change the connection type on my S8.) It seems the designer of the V30's audio never listened very carefully with sensitive IEMs. I'm afraid I don't know of a work-around for this BT issue, other than keeping the receiver really close to the V30 so that the connection quality doesn't drop and degrade. When it works, it sounds similar to the S8, but I suspect the V30 has the weaker BT radio.
P.S. It's bizarre how quickly Tidal are now filling out their MQA catalogue. One could become cynical seeing how apparently easy it is to create MQA equivalents!
I did the same tests with Focal Utopias (balanced and single-ended into the XB10) and then the AAC and AptX HD were much closer - I struggle to hear any re-sampling artifacts on higher-impedance/lower-sensitivity headphones.
Whatever weird things the XB10 is doing may be manifesting itself slightly differently in your headphones, but what I hear in AAC mode is the amp on the XB10 completely cuts out in those moments of silence, and then turns back on again when the music kicks in again. The clicks are quite audible at those points, so we're probably hearing the same effect.
I went back to my Samsung S8 (aptX support, but not aptX HD) and played the same track through the Tidal app on that. It sounded similar to that of the V30 at its best when using aptX HD - but overall the S8 was more consistent, so I'd have the say the S8 was the winner. (I have no option to change the connection type on my S8.) It seems the designer of the V30's audio never listened very carefully with sensitive IEMs. I'm afraid I don't know of a work-around for this BT issue, other than keeping the receiver really close to the V30 so that the connection quality doesn't drop and degrade. When it works, it sounds similar to the S8, but I suspect the V30 has the weaker BT radio.
P.S. It's bizarre how quickly Tidal are now filling out their MQA catalogue. One could become cynical seeing how apparently easy it is to create MQA equivalents!