Quote:
Originally Posted by TheMarchingMule /img/forum/go_quote.gif
M'kay, before I start, let me say I'm primarily a Stax and Grado guy, followed by a liking of Etymotic products.
Okay, to me, no matter what tips and/or ports I tired, the highs felt thin, the mids were fubar'd like the V-Mode Vibes (namely the percussion sounded out of phase so much), and the bass was too warm. Like, Sennheiser warm, but the accuracy was starting to lean off the scale and be boomy.
I've been bashed and flamed before for those statements, but it's how I honestly heard them. So if anybody wants to waste their breath with criticism, go for it; I'm not listening.
|
No criticism here. I own the ER4Ps, SA6 and my favorite, the UM2. I rarely listen to the Etys and listen to the UM2 all the time. I find the UM2 to be near perfect for sound quality, just right in the highs and awesome mids as well as super tight and accurate bass....there's a relevant point to this, trust me....and just couldn't think of a better sounding canalphone.
Here's the point -
I picked up my ER4Ps and used them for about an hour one day last week and immediately I was struck by how bright sounding they were. Just absolute bright highs but I went on and used them bearing through the highs because I knew my ears would adjust and they'd begin sounding good to me.
After an hour or so I went back to the UM2 and was struck by how dull they sounded and how lacking of treble they were. They sounded exactly like you described of the SA6, the boominess and all. I knew they were the best canalphones I had ever heard, though, because I found them to be so through the last week.
The point is, if anyone uses a very bright canalphone like the Etymotics, Altecs, Harman Kardons and such, let your ears adjust to anything else before you condemn them.
I had to get my ears adjusted back down to normal levels of treble by using progressively less trebled canalphones before I could listen to the UM2 again and like them. I do love them and cannot find a better sounding canalphone but the Etys had my hearing way skewed.