MHDT Labs: R-2R NOS Tube DACs
Aug 28, 2023 at 10:59 PM Post #796 of 895
anyone have comparisions with the orchard vs the 264 bifrost. i am considering buying the orchard at the moment
Never heard the bifrost but very satisfied with my Orchid, very sweet sound that feels natural to my ears. The only small flaw I ear is it has a bit less sparkles with electronic type sounds. I'd love to compare it to a good R2R DAC one day because these seem like a modern evolution of the NOS sweet sound we get from the Orchid.
 
Aug 29, 2023 at 12:30 AM Post #797 of 895
i have the xspdif2 and haven't noticed a change when powering it with hdplex's 9v dc. however, i also have the matrix H usb card and it does benefit from external psu. tho, as i understand it, these two devices are not actually powered by external psu.

when i had the orchid, i didn't use a ddc. i am really kicking myself for it as i really like these older r2r chip based dacs when fed by a ddc. my favorite right now is a rod rain pcm1796 based dac fed by a singxer su-6.
 
Aug 29, 2023 at 2:09 PM Post #798 of 895
anyone have comparisions with the orchard vs the 264 bifrost. i am considering buying the orchard at the moment
I don't have the Orchid but I do have the MHDT Pagoda and Steeplechase and the Bifrost. Both the Pagoda and Steeplechase are a very large improvement over the Bifrost. Don't get me wrong I love the Bifrost especially for it's price point but the MHDT DACs are noticeably better in nearly every category.
 
Aug 29, 2023 at 4:57 PM Post #799 of 895
i have the xspdif2 and haven't noticed a change when powering it with hdplex's 9v dc. however, i also have the matrix H usb card and it does benefit from external psu. tho, as i understand it, these two devices are not actually powered by external psu.

when i had the orchid, i didn't use a ddc. i am really kicking myself for it as i really like these older r2r chip based dacs when fed by a ddc. my favorite right now is a rod rain pcm1796 based dac fed by a singxer su-6.
I use that very same DDC with my Orchid. I was already getting a nice sound from the Orchid using a SPDIF converter + the best coax cable I know of. Then I swapped in the Matrix DDC everything got a little bit better, especially focus, channel separation, and space around notes.

I have no reason to lust after other DACs. This one totally works for me.
 
Aug 29, 2023 at 5:01 PM Post #800 of 895
I don't have the Orchid but I do have the MHDT Pagoda and Steeplechase and the Bifrost. Both the Pagoda and Steeplechase are a very large improvement over the Bifrost. Don't get me wrong I love the Bifrost especially for it's price point but the MHDT DACs are noticeably better in nearly every category.
Never even heard of the Steeplechase.

Are you covered with dirt and clumps of sod after listening to it?
 
Aug 29, 2023 at 7:53 PM Post #801 of 895
Never even heard of the Steeplechase.

Are you covered with dirt and clumps of sod after listening to it?
Lol! Happy to report no. It's one of their previous generation of DACs. I've also owned MHDT Paradesia + and Havana DACs from previous generations. They are all very musical and very analogue sounding. Coming from a vinyl background this is exactly the sound I was looking for.
 
Aug 29, 2023 at 8:49 PM Post #802 of 895
Coming from a vinyl background this is exactly the sound I was looking for
Exactly right. I had a huge love affair w/vinyl all through the '80s, big TT,big system, 1000s of LPs. Started having CD players, then DACs,~1986. It wasn't until ~25 years later, when I got my first NOS DAC, that digital started sounding like music. 2 NOS and one multibit DAC later, I'm right where I need to be.
 
Sep 29, 2023 at 10:14 AM Post #803 of 895
Is there any sonic comparison between Orchid and Orchid69SE? As I see the tube families used are different.

Also, when I check the price of the product, there is 69SE, 69SE S1 and 69SE S2, each 100 usd more expensive than the previous

I wonder what is the difference in components inbetween those Orchids, and is there any increase in sonic quality or maybe more feature

EDIT: One more question, After going through the thread, I saw that the preference is to use DDC to Orchid.
If my streamer can output to SPDIF/Coax would a DDC still be necessary?
I want to keep things simple and not to add more box to the chain.
 
Last edited:
Sep 29, 2023 at 11:13 AM Post #804 of 895
Is there any sonic comparison between Orchid and Orchid69SE? As I see the tube families used are different.

Also, when I check the price of the product, there is 69SE, 69SE S1 and 69SE S2, each 100 usd more expensive than the previous

I wonder what is the difference in components inbetween those Orchids, and is there any increase in sonic quality or maybe more feature

EDIT: One more question, After going through the thread, I saw that the preference is to use DDC to Orchid.
If my streamer can output to SPDIF/Coax would a DDC still be necessary?
I want to keep things simple and not to add more box to the chain.
I wouldn't ever add an extra box to the chain that isn't necessary. I imagine you'll get a difference in sound that's not necessarily an improvement.

DDCs make sense to me if you have an output/input mismatch. Otherwise I wouldn't do it.
 
Sep 29, 2023 at 12:13 PM Post #805 of 895
I have the original Orchid and love it. I've been tempted by the 69SE but never been able to justify spending for it and just like all MHDT products, it's difficult to find much info.

The DDC subject has also tempted me a bit lately since I often use an Apple Macbook and an iPhone as source and from what I read it seems to make a positive difference feeding many DACs that don't have a great parts in their USB input.
 
Sep 29, 2023 at 1:44 PM Post #806 of 895
If my streamer can output to SPDIF/Coax would a DDC still be necessary?
Very likely, yes. The reason is that a DDC reclocks the digital signal, as well as converts the USB input to a SPDIF input to the DAC (coax or optical). Depending on the DAC used, the DDC's reclocking may well produce sonic benefits.

In addition, some DDCs, such as my Matrix Audio X-SPDIF2, also outputs the digital signal via I2S. My Orchid does not have an I2S input, but if I ever use a DAC that has one, I2S is often described as the very best sonic alternative to USB.
 
Oct 9, 2023 at 7:34 PM Post #807 of 895
I don't have the Orchid but I do have the MHDT Pagoda and Steeplechase and the Bifrost. Both the Pagoda and Steeplechase are a very large improvement over the Bifrost. Don't get me wrong I love the Bifrost especially for it's price point but the MHDT DACs are noticeably better in nearly every category.

good to know

i am currently deceiding between the pagoda or orchard at the moment as my next dac

i only own the 264 atm
 
Oct 10, 2023 at 8:44 AM Post #809 of 895
I had the Orchid as my primary DAC for years and loved it - there are a few for sale right now on US AudioMart - just a heads up.
I’m in the same boat David, loving the Orchid for years now but haven’t found a decent replacement without having to morgage my house! Which DAC did you finally go for? I would love to find a battery driven « transportable » DAC to replace my Orchid because I like to listen to music in different spots, I use a Woo WA8 amp for that purpose but the internal ESS based DAC does not give me the same satisfaction as when I sit down at my desk and connect it to the Orchid. Thanks.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top