Well, most idol group music I don't consider the type that shows off vocal skills. I think they are usually produced in a way the vocals sounds rigid due to several members singing different part. Idol music is mix of catchy phrases. I do get a good idea of idol's talent in instances when they perform solo like Wendy or Joy.
I don't think Blackpink members are great singers when I listen to their singing. BTS has members that is very capable. SM Entertainment generally puts in members with vocal skills.
I thought of another interesting feat that kpop has achieved. If we look at streaming services, kpop is a separate genre well recognized. I was looking through Tidal, and ther is a kpop genre, but not jpop. This reflects that kpop is internationally recognized to the point of being a genre of it's own.
Yeah, agreed. I also think that, while BTS and BP have done a great job of widening Kpop to a huge amount of people, I just get sad when people ONLY know about those two groups. Even though I don't listen to boy groups, BTS does have a fairly well balanced discography but BP basically has the same sound in all of their songs - which is still a measly low count of songs considering the time they've been active. This is of course no fault of the girls, but more YG's fault. But still. Kpop has a lot more to offer than those two groups.
That's why I'm very happy to see people here actually listening to many other groups, and many of those that I also listen to! Like Red Velvet, Mamamoo, (G)I-DLE, Dreamcatcher, Everglow, etc. Even the more uncommon groups like Woo!Ah! and 3YE which is heartwarming to see!
In regards to live performance singing skills, it's very weird. Before Kpop I was very very aware of how people sing live (or lack of singing, with backing tracks, etc), and consider myself both a musician and an audiophile. With Kpop it's just different. It just makes me happy, regardless if they're singing or using heavy backing tracks. While some groups surely does a better job than others with live singing (like Mamamoo), and always brings out the musician in me, I can enjoy performances with 100% backing tracks as well if the choreo is very demanding. It's gotten to the point where I just get happy to see them, even before the song starts... it's very illogical.
But perhaps music sometimes is supposed to be felt - not analyzed
Last edited: