Until today I'd spent probably a combined total of 10 minutes listening to a friend's 5g iPod and another friend's 2g Nano. I don't do much portable listening and the only mp3 player I own is the original handgo jukebox ... which actually sounds not bad but is big, clunky, and has lousy battery life.
Today however I took my Shure E4c's to the Mac Store and spent 1 1/2 hours listening to the same two tracks rotating between the Nano 3g, iPod Classic, and iTouch. Primarily, I'd like to have some sort of player to use through the line-in of my car stereo. In sound quality, to my ears, the iTouch sounded best by a long shot. My next choice would be the Nano, with the Classic coming in a close last. I found both the Nano and Classic to have a thin, harsh, tinny sound to them while the iTouch sounded much better balanced and warmer .... but still with plenty of detail. This surprised me because I generally like emphasised highs (probably because of my age and therefore declining sensitivity to frequency response) and while both the Nano and Classic seemed to have emphasized highs ( and not much bass...at least with the Shures) the brittle harshness made them both seem irritating, while again, the iTouch sounded much more natural and smooth.
The touch screen was fun to play with, but sometimes. like many touch screens, I found myself having to make a second or third attempt to get it to do what I wanted .... although this could also be due to the fact that i didn't really know what I was doing most of the time.
The only thing that kept me from buying one on the spot was the price. I've been burned so many times by being an early adopter, and I have no doubt that a price reduction and/or improved model is already just around the corner....but even as i'm typing this, i'm thinking of going back to the store and getting one.
Does anyone know whether or not you can use it to store and transfer regular files ( such as documents or even applications) from a Mac computer? That ability would likely close the deal for me.