I have been downloading quite a few recordings from HDTracks in 24/88.2 or 24/96 in the past but never really went back to compare to 16/44.1 version I would happen to already own. But tonight, I did this comparison for Beck's "Sea Change" recording and I am glad I did!
To put it shorlty, you're wasting money downloading hi-rez tracks .... ... ... Not! Just kidding, the difference is definitely present and the revelation for me is that it's not just high frequency extension / shimmer. It just takes me to whole new place and feels much more natural. This Beck album is my favorite of the bunch and I feel it is very engaging emotionally. Well, call this placebo effect if you will but the 24/88.2 version transports me even more...
It's actually a bit difficult to precisely quantify what is going on but it all simply sounds just more right on the HDTrack 24/88.2 version. The cymbals have more texture, the dynamics seems increased (or maybe the background noise is reduced?), even the bass impact seems more real. The voice is definitely not shrill on the previous 16/44.1 recording (which I always considered very good on its own) but it does sound a bit sharp compared to the 24/88.2 version. Same goes with acoustic guitar attacks. There is more depth / better instrument separation on the 24/88.2. The list goes on, it is just simply amazing, I really did not expect that much difference.
Now even more interesting, I thought 90% of this had to do with the quality of the mastering, such that the 24/88.2 version downsampled and decimated to 16/44.1 (using Itunes) would pretty much sound the same as the original. Well, it doesn't. For one, we can clearly tell the new 24/88.2 is a new mastering (I have zero information on it though, as usually from HD Tracks) as the downsampled / decimated version clearly sounds different from the previous 16/44.1 version. Additionally, most of the magic I experienced with the 24/88.2 version is actually missing when listening to the downsampled / decimated version. It feels like going from lossless to a high quality lossy format. It sounds good but somehow it has lost the magic.
As for associated equipment: Macbook Pro (2011) >>> Audio-gd DI >>> Yamamoto YDA-01 >>> Stax SRM-727a>>> Stax SR-007a. One thing to note: the player is Audirvana and it is actually upsampling the 24/88.2 to 24/96 because the Audio-GD Digital Interface does not support 88.2kHz feed. I assume one would get even better results with an interface that does not resample...
My apologies if this mini-review is not very precise or clear. I did not intend to make any review at all actually, but it just sounds soo awesome I felt this had to be shared!