Gustard U16 - the first USB Interface featuring ESS USB chip
Aug 10, 2019 at 3:11 PM Post #1,216 of 1,697
Many reports here say "FW v1.61 NFB" is more stable. Therefore, I spend some time to repeat the test procedure I did for the other FW versions in the past:

(HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738080

(BNC out)-> Hugo 2 (coax in):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738086

(XLR/coax/toslink output)-> RME ADI-2 pro (XLR/coax/toslink input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738094


Summary for FW Version 1.61 NFB (GU16V1_61_NFB.rom) (https://onedrive.live.com/?id=636DC4E8060D66A1!380&cid=636DC4E8060D66A1)

"v1.61 NFB" indeed works nearly as expected. Only one (and a half) issue are left to my notes:
  • Using (HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input) at PCM/176/24 music is sometimes distorted. Not distorted like in the past, when I needed to tear the cans from the head quickly, but clearly the music is badly effected. The problem can be solved by switching inputs on the AudioGD R7. It looks like a kind of sync problem. Anyhow there are no issues at all with Singxer SU-1.
  • No RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz came through. The RME can not even establish a sync to the U16 for the test files. Strange! The other 96 kHz and 44kHz RME Bit Tests where past without a problem with all bit depths. Again on Singer SU-1 also the RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz passes. However, this is a more theoretical test,I did not discover issues with 192kHz music files so far.
Please find detailed test results below.
Please note, when you see "not playing (OK)", this means is not an U16 issue. There are other limitations like interface speed/specification or DAC specification.
Please also note, that I had updated Aries Femto and RME ADI-2 Firmwares, since the last tests. Not sure, if this had an effect, but you never know for sure...

upload_2019-8-10_21-2-54.png

upload_2019-8-10_21-3-53.png


So all in all it look quite good. Will continue with U16. Hope it will be stable.
 
Aug 10, 2019 at 5:27 PM Post #1,217 of 1,697
Many reports here say "FW v1.61 NFB" is more stable. Therefore, I spend some time to repeat the test procedure I did for the other FW versions in the past:

(HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738080

(BNC out)-> Hugo 2 (coax in):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738086

(XLR/coax/toslink output)-> RME ADI-2 pro (XLR/coax/toslink input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738094


Summary for FW Version 1.61 NFB (GU16V1_61_NFB.rom) (https://onedrive.live.com/?id=636DC4E8060D66A1!380&cid=636DC4E8060D66A1)

"v1.61 NFB" indeed works nearly as expected. Only one (and a half) issue are left to my notes:
  • Using (HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input) at PCM/176/24 music is sometimes distorted. Not distorted like in the past, when I needed to tear the cans from the head quickly, but clearly the music is badly effected. The problem can be solved by switching inputs on the AudioGD R7. It looks like a kind of sync problem. Anyhow there are no issues at all with Singxer SU-1.
  • No RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz came through. The RME can not even establish a sync to the U16 for the test files. Strange! The other 96 kHz and 44kHz RME Bit Tests where past without a problem with all bit depths. Again on Singer SU-1 also the RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz passes. However, this is a more theoretical test,I did not discover issues with 192kHz music files so far.
Please find detailed test results below.
Please note, when you see "not playing (OK)", this means is not an U16 issue. There are other limitations like interface speed/specification or DAC specification.
Please also note, that I had updated Aries Femto and RME ADI-2 Firmwares, since the last tests. Not sure, if this had an effect, but you never know for sure...




So all in all it look quite good. Will continue with U16. Hope it will be stable.
I confirmed the issue with r7 and 176k files.
 
Aug 10, 2019 at 7:37 PM Post #1,218 of 1,697
Many reports here say "FW v1.61 NFB" is more stable. Therefore, I spend some time to repeat the test procedure I did for the other FW versions in the past:

(HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738080

(BNC out)-> Hugo 2 (coax in):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738086

(XLR/coax/toslink output)-> RME ADI-2 pro (XLR/coax/toslink input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738094


Summary for FW Version 1.61 NFB (GU16V1_61_NFB.rom) (https://onedrive.live.com/?id=636DC4E8060D66A1!380&cid=636DC4E8060D66A1)

"v1.61 NFB" indeed works nearly as expected. Only one (and a half) issue are left to my notes:
  • Using (HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input) at PCM/176/24 music is sometimes distorted. Not distorted like in the past, when I needed to tear the cans from the head quickly, but clearly the music is badly effected. The problem can be solved by switching inputs on the AudioGD R7. It looks like a kind of sync problem. Anyhow there are no issues at all with Singxer SU-1.
  • No RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz came through. The RME can not even establish a sync to the U16 for the test files. Strange! The other 96 kHz and 44kHz RME Bit Tests where past without a problem with all bit depths. Again on Singer SU-1 also the RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz passes. However, this is a more theoretical test,I did not discover issues with 192kHz music files so far.
Please find detailed test results below.
Please note, when you see "not playing (OK)", this means is not an U16 issue. There are other limitations like interface speed/specification or DAC specification.
Please also note, that I had updated Aries Femto and RME ADI-2 Firmwares, since the last tests. Not sure, if this had an effect, but you never know for sure...




So all in all it look quite good. Will continue with U16. Hope it will be stable.

This is what a professional QA person gets paid to do. Your hired!
 
Aug 12, 2019 at 12:27 AM Post #1,219 of 1,697
Many reports here say "FW v1.61 NFB" is more stable. Therefore, I spend some time to repeat the test procedure I did for the other FW versions in the past:

(HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738080

(BNC out)-> Hugo 2 (coax in):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738086

(XLR/coax/toslink output)-> RME ADI-2 pro (XLR/coax/toslink input):
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/gus...ing-ess-usb-chip.888947/page-32#post-14738094


Summary for FW Version 1.61 NFB (GU16V1_61_NFB.rom) (https://onedrive.live.com/?id=636DC4E8060D66A1!380&cid=636DC4E8060D66A1)

"v1.61 NFB" indeed works nearly as expected. Only one (and a half) issue are left to my notes:
  • Using (HDMI/IIS)-> AudioGD R7 (IIS input) at PCM/176/24 music is sometimes distorted. Not distorted like in the past, when I needed to tear the cans from the head quickly, but clearly the music is badly effected. The problem can be solved by switching inputs on the AudioGD R7. It looks like a kind of sync problem. Anyhow there are no issues at all with Singxer SU-1.
  • No RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz came through. The RME can not even establish a sync to the U16 for the test files. Strange! The other 96 kHz and 44kHz RME Bit Tests where past without a problem with all bit depths. Again on Singer SU-1 also the RME Bit-Tests for 192kHz passes. However, this is a more theoretical test,I did not discover issues with 192kHz music files so far.
Please find detailed test results below.
Please note, when you see "not playing (OK)", this means is not an U16 issue. There are other limitations like interface speed/specification or DAC specification.
Please also note, that I had updated Aries Femto and RME ADI-2 Firmwares, since the last tests. Not sure, if this had an effect, but you never know for sure...




So all in all it look quite good. Will continue with U16. Hope it will be stable.
nice job!!
 
Aug 12, 2019 at 8:59 AM Post #1,221 of 1,697
my ebay seller had the 10M antenna available so hopefully no problem....
I will be traveling for a few weeks, so will report back the results when I return.
thanks again for the heads-up on this device :beerchug:

Hi Folks,

I got this installed OK, very easy to setup with a 10 meter cable (was 8 USD from my eBay vendor), just dropped the antenna box out a window - it is hanging free on a bar from the window security screen with a fairly open sight to clear sky. No problem with the GPS lock. I made some preliminary observations at the link below.. using now for a couple days with great results.

https://www.head-fi.org/threads/new...tor-ladder-dacs.853902/page-322#post-15117230

(Even my Teresa Teng Greatest Hits files sounded surprisingly well recorded & refined, we must have low phase noise satellites on this side of the globe :ksc75smile: )
 
Aug 12, 2019 at 9:36 AM Post #1,222 of 1,697
Edited: The Ebay disciplined clock units have OCXOs. But the descriptions are vague and performance is sketchy until proven. I'm taking @FredA 's approach and putting my money in an OCXO only design. If I can't see a datasheet for the clock then I'm not buying.
 

Attachments

  • s-l500.jpg
    s-l500.jpg
    14.3 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
Aug 12, 2019 at 9:59 AM Post #1,223 of 1,697
10 MHz Satellite Disciplined Clock buyers beware of the units that look like this and sell for around $125-$135 US. This design uses a Blox NEO-6 satellite receiver chip with integrated TCXO. Designed mainly for long term stability and not necessarily low jitter.


The units with the nice LCD panels that sell above $160 US at least have OCXOs. But the descriptions are vague and performance is sketchy until proven. I'm taking @FredA 's approach and putting my money in an OCXO only design. If I can't see a datasheet for the clock then I'm not buying.
I am still not convinced with mine. If the d.. 50ohm cable can come in...
 
Last edited:
Aug 12, 2019 at 10:17 AM Post #1,226 of 1,697
Thank you! Finally something with specs...

The $130 Ebay discipline clocks units I trashed above have the OCXOs mounted from the bottom side of the board. I was only scanning the top side of the board. Thanks for the correction....
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top