Last night I had the opportunity to spend some time at another local audiophiles home comparing the Gustard R26 and Pontus II. This was very fortuitous as these are the two main DAC’s that I’ve been interested in as an upgrade to my Ares II. His system is speaker based and I’ve not heard this particular setup before so I took my AWAS and Gilmore Lite MkII and GRPS so I could listen on something more familiar.
The setup is a pair of the omni-directional Duevel Bella Luna’s powered by a Rogue Audio Pharaoh. The DAC’s are sourced from a Sonore opticalRendu streaming from Tidal/Roon. This setup is in a loft space I’d estimate at 10’ wide x 12’ deep but it could be a bit bigger. There is a half wall that is open to the living room below. Coming up the stairs from the living room below, there is a couch at the top of the stairs on the half wall and another on back wall opposite. The components are on a shelf beside the couch on the back wall with the speakers out a couple of feet in front of the couch on the back wall and a couple of feet in from the back wall. My assumption for the “sweet spot” was the couch on the half wall but I was mistaken, it’s actually the couch on the back wall closest to the speakers.
We first listened to the R26 on this setup and I was absolutely floored. The speakers completely disappeared with the front of the soundstage about where the couch on the half wall, probably 6 to 8 feet behind the speakers, covering the full width of space. Not only was the soundstage jaw dropping, but overall balance, tone and detail were spot on. We listened to number of tracks on the speakers, some I was familiar with some I wasn’t, but it all sounded excellent. I could almost see the performers on the stage. They had space around them, depth where there should be depth and instruments sounded correct to my ear.
This had me pretty excited to hear the R26 with my AWAS so we swapped IC’s to the Gilmore Lite Mk II but ended up being pretty let down. In my setup, the R26 sounded lean a touch on the bright side of what I’m used to hearing via the Ares II. It seemed very “matter of fact” lacking some warmth and tonal richness. I listened to a few of the same songs we had listened to with the Bella Luna’s but that magic just wasn’t there. From here we swapped to the Pontus II which proved to be a much better match, smoother, with richer tone, more overall weight and less aggressive treble.
To cap things off, we then went back to the speaker setup but using the Pontus II instead of the R26. This proved to be quite enlightening. The Pontus II sounded nice, those same characteristics I heard on my headphones showing through but in this case to the detriment of the sound. It was very obvious that the Pontus II is a bit rolled off in the treble and more emphasized in the bass which threw off the balance that seemed almost perfect with the R26. It was also pretty apparent that the Pontus II isn’t quite as accomplished in the technical areas. Again, it sounded very nice and involving in its own way, but for me at least, I lost that sense of being there, if that makes sense.
I came away feeling a bit confused by all this. There’s no doubt in my mind the R26 is the better DAC but the synergy in my setup was not good. If I were to buy one, I think it would need to be paired with a tube amp to bring out some warmth and richness and in the end, maybe never find the right pairing. When I got home, I listened to some of the same tracks with the Ares II and honestly felt like it was best match. Not as smooth as the Pontus II, but seemed to have a weightier, more dynamic sound which brings the AWAS to life. I'm thinking now I might actually try an Ares 12th and see how that compares to the Ares II.