Quote:
Originally posted by blessingx
FalconP had some good suggestions in the Masterpiece thread. |
Thanks Blessing
There has been quite a number of things in this thread already, I'll go to each of that:
1) For someone wanting a taste for Celtic music, I'd recommend something "lighter" and more new-agey,
preferably by musicians with good trad credentials -- "hard-core" traditionalists take a bit of getting used to, as they may sound bland and repetitive for beginners; I personally had difficulties with Altan at first -- not
their problem, of course
So, which CDs to start with?
Song of the Irish Whistle vol.1 by Joannie Madden, front-lady of Cherish the Ladies. The best playing of Irish whistle you can hope for, with cutting-edge, innovative arrangements. There is a second volume, but it is little more than glorified elevator music and is best avoided.
A Different Shore by Nightnoise: the credentials of the members of this (sadly defunct) group is beyond repoach. On this CD they have taken a more laid-back and somewhat "jazzy" approach to Celtic music. Pensive, romantic moments are perfectly balanced by bright-colured, uplifting dances.
The Leaving of Ireland by Jon Mark and David Antony Clark: despite the lack of stellar players, there is no question about the playing there. A mixture of traditional instrumental, songs, narration, and ambient soundscapes, this concept album works wonderfully -- it is almost like watching a film or a documentry about the Irish people leaving for the New World.
Legends by James Galway and Phil Coulter -- before this album I never think James Galways can play traditional music (his collaboration manages to bring the Chieftains down). I think he's learned the knack here, and many tunes on this set are famous and was elegantly arranged.
2) On Clannad: there are two phases in their career -- the "traditional" phase and the "new age" phase, with the album
Anam as the dividing line. With a few exceptions their traditional albums can be hard to come by -- get
Clannad in Concert (1989, Shanachie) if you still can; otherwise at least
Fuaim should be readily available. Amongst their latter "new-age" releases,
Lore stands head and shoulders above the rest in every way -- if you can just have one Clannad album and don't want a sampler, then
Lore is the one.
3) On the Chieftains: I can go on for days but I'll be quick -- basically, even though people think that the Chieftains are "the ambassadors of Irish music", their style is
very idiosyncratic and I simply can't think of anyone else who plays like them (possible exception is the mid-80s
Boys of the Lough, and even they sounded more polite than the Chieftains).
Their sound has changed somewhat throughout the years, becoming more "streamlined" and more chamber-music-like: it is interesting to compare early gems (like
Chieftains 9: Boil the Breakfast Early with recent masterpieces like
Water from the Well, noting that it was the same group of person playing on both sets!
As for the fusion projects that the Chieftains are notorious about, I think two has aged particularly well:
Celtic Wedding -- music of Brittany and
Another Country.
4) Beyond the Scots and the Irish -- Second KR's recommendation for Milladoiro -- if you have to get just one CD from them it is their live set
As Fadas De Estrano Nome -- almost 70 minutes of great music. Although I'm not terribly impressed by their latest
Auga de Maio.
The French Celtic community in Brittany is also famous for musicians -- although many of these are more interested in fusion than tradition: Dan Ar Braz is reasonably well known, and his "Héritage Des Celtes" series has spawned a few grand-sounding, star-studded releases. I also enjoy the trad-rock outfit
Tri Yann, but their CDs are simply too hard to come by,
Wales is famous for their chromatic "triple harp" (leading exponent: Robin Huw Bowen); apart from that, don't know much about Welsh music.
5) About the term "Celtic" -- this term has been used so imprecisely that it is difficult to use it without inviting misunderstanding:
Celtic is basically a linguistic definition. (although reputable medical texts do use it for persons with a specific kind of ancestry, or specific physical features). When refering to a style of music it is a harmless and convenient (but imprecise) catch-all phase (but I prefer to say "Scots-Irish" or whatever, unless I indeed need a catch-all phase). Outside music, this word is probably best reserved for linguistians.
Note: hyperlinks coming.