Hi everyone,
atsq sold me one of his Geek Pulse XFi DAC/Amps (he apparently bought three from the original campaign), and asked me what I thought - I've had it now for three weeks and wanted to add my thoughts, such as they are, because I noticed the relative lack of reviews compared to other DACs.
My experience with DACs are as follows: Creative ZxR -> Schiit Modi -> Burson Conductor SL (PCM1793) -> Geek Pulse XFi -> Geek Pulse XFi with Jays Audio LPS
My desire to upgrade my DAC was to chase the seemingly neverending goal of the perfect sound, which for me involved extended highs without harshness, clear full mids and good bass and sub-bass impact and texture, all coupled with a wide and layered soundstage. I chose the HD800 as my end-game headphone due to its reputation as the king of soundstage, knowing full well that it would need a picky DAC/Amp. The closest to meeting my goal was the Burson Conductor, but despite this, the highs were too harsh and bright for me with the HD800.
So, onto my mini-review:
The Geek Pulse XFi wasn't much to look at in my hands, but it was securely packaged by LH Labs. Wasting no time, I plugged in the Wall-Wart (stock power supply), my HD800s using the stock single ended cable and a Chord Silverplus USB cable, hoping to blown away by the sound...
To my horror, the sound was in a word, brittle - the harsh in the highs that I heard on the Burson remained, though in smaller volume. The soundstage was wider and slightly more layered but less cohesive than the Burson, though how much that was from the Burson amp or PCM1793 DAC, I don't know. The mids were forward, and because I listen to alot of vocals, it does seem, as been described before, like the volume was on too loud (-30.5 dB on the Geek Pulse screen). The bass was present with good texture and not muddy at all, but somewhat lacking in impact.
I did a little research, and people were recommending using the Linear Power Supply - because I had not been a member of the original campaign, I thought paying 600 USD for the LPS to be a bit much, especially since I bought the Pulse for a little more than that. Alvin1188 here was selling a Jay Audio LPS for about half the price, so I bought one, and after 10 days of waiting around and being distracted at work, I plugged in the LPS and gave it another go...
The difference in sound, to my amateur ears, was not subtle - dynamics improved dramatically, where everything sounded loud before, I could more easily discern softer passages of music. The bass improved mildly in impact, but still didn't have enough oomph. Soundstage width and depth was mildly better, and I could catch a glimpse of why the HD800s are so highly regarded - only a glimpse, mind you! The highs seemed less harsh, but with the harshness lessening, I noticed a lack of energy. The cymbals now had better decay and texture, but lacked a bit of energy. The vocals were much improved, with more detail present.
Given I paid 200 USD for the LPS, I could have easily stopped here with a reasonable setup for the HD800s - but by now I had been bitten by the upgraditis bug - because the HD800s still cost me more the DAC/Amp and LPS, I sorely wanted to give them a good chance of shining. So tried my existing standalone amplifiers:
The Violectric V200 amplifer (using balanced interconnects) certainly provided the bass impact and improved the dynamicism, but felt the dynamics were a little jarring, as if the transition between soft and loud passages were over exaggered, without a smooth transition. Detail was certainly lost compared to the built-in amp of the Geek Pulse. The biggest turn-off, and the reason why I have put up my V200 for sale, is that the soundstage was much more narrowed on the V200, almost to the same width as my Hifiman HE-500s, which are not renowned for their soundstage width and depth!
The big surprise, however, was how well my Schiit Valhalla mk1 OTL amplifier performed - the highs were smoother but had a little sparkle in them that excited me! The mids were richer with a little loss of detail. The soundstage was much wider than the V200, and indeed more cohesive than the Geek Pulse's amp, but in the enveloping sound (akin to the Burson Conductor), I lost some of the instrument separation and localisation, noticeable with the orchestral pieces. Still, this was the first amp where I could lose my eyes and be lost in the music.
The Valhalla showed me that the Geek Pulse's DAC was certainly up to the task, much more than the PCM1793, of providing me with the detail I wanted, but alas, the on-board amplifer was not a good match for the HD800s. I then decided to research Head-Fi, Computer Audiophile and other forums for "the best amp for the HD800", and while that is a discussion that is still ongoing in these forums, my budget and store availability led me to buy the HDVA600 and CH800S.
Now with my wallet truly crying for mercy >_<, I plugged in my completely balanced system and had a listen:
One word: perfection! Smooth extended highs with just enough energy to send shivers down my spine, full rich mids with detail, textured bass with impact (though not as much as the V200 admittedly), but my goodness, the soundstage! The best of the lot, and finally I could see what everyone was on about with the HD800s - I could picture myself in the auditorium, and hear where the instruments were, not only to my left or right, higher or lower than me but also how FAR they were! I read about people going on about soundstage depth, but never understood it until now.
Just out of curiosity, I plugged my balanced cable (CH800S) into the 4 pin XLR slot of my Geek Pulse, and to my surprise and chargin, the HD800s performed almost as well as the HDVA600!! Roughly speaking, probably about 80% of the performance, for the cost of a balanced cable.
So my my final thoughts on the Geek Pulse XFi are:
- The DAC is excellent for its price, and a much better implementation of the ESS9018 chip than my Glove Audio A1 and Aurender Flow,
- The onboard amp, at least for the HD800s, needs a balanced cable or better yet, a discrete amplifier, and,
- A linear power supply is an absolute must!
While I never suffered the frustrations of waiting for a product from LH Labs, here is one happy user of their products!