Put simply, the first question you need to ask yourself is this:
Do I really want or need custom IEMs?
If you do - read on. If you don't, don't waste your money and be happy with your TF10, SE530, ED 9, HD 650, etc.
Custom IEMs have their rewards and tradeoffs just like everything else. I will leave effusive praise for or sharp criticism of the UE-11 to others.
See the following threads:
http://www.head-fi.org/forums/f103/c...l-iems-346851/
http://www.head-fi.org/forums/f103/f...ssions-251338/
Quote:
Originally Posted by ace8888 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
So, it's not worth approx 4x the price for the upgrade?
|
In terms of performance per dollar, no. Nothing beats my Yuin PK3 in terms of performance/dollar.
However, no other IEM that sounds like the UE-11, so if you really have to have that UE-11 sound, then you have no choice but to spend the money.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ace8888 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Really.. does it sound that good? Will I notice a huge leap of sound quality?
|
Yes and Yes. And also a huge leap in comfort only if the impression was done right, and you are okay with having a larger volume in your ear (outer and ear canal). Some people, though, can't get a good fit no matter what they seem to do.
What do they sound like?
Take the Bass of the Atrio M5/8 + SE530
Add the Midrange of the SE530 and UM2
and Add the Treble of the TF10
Then add a nice soundstage and detail
Combine all of that and you have some idea what the UE-11 sounds like.
Combine all those IEMs, and that's roughly how much the UE-11 costs after impressions and shipping.
Not to say that you are guaranteed to like the UE-11. The bass can be a bit much for some. The amount of bass reminds me of the bass you'll feel at a live concert or a movie theater. Despite the bass, the detail and midrange never get overwhelmed. The treble might be a bit much for those who think the S530 has too much treble, but detail-freaks will be pleased. The midrange is not as lush as speakers or good full-size headphones.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ace8888 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
...there will be no residual value whatsoever, $0 value, it's a life-keeper...
|
...therefore upgrades and sidegrades are costly. My only other customs - Livewires - will not see much use now that I have my UE-11.
With universal IEMs, you can slowly upgrade. You can't really do this with customs - so when you're ready for customs, reach for the sky.
"Don't settle for 2nd best when getting married" - remember that advice? Well, you can't divorce your custom IEM and file for palimony/alimony. However, UE and LW have 'universal fit' customs to let you experience the sound signature of their customs - contact them to find a dealer that has these demo customs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ace8888 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Is it worth the upgrade?
|
A qualified NO.
UE-11 pros - they're not life-changing (other than potential financial adversity, being ridiculed for spending so much on earphones, etc). I've heard better-sounding full-sized headphone setups for about the same cost. My $80 Ety ER6 gives my ears just as good isolation. Customs do not provide enough isolation for use in a shooting range. Some universal IEMs are almost as comfortable. You can't share the UE-11 experience with anybody else. Crappy MP3s sound terrible (but great recordings sound phenomenal). Any weak component in the chain (e.g unamped iPod) will reveal itself.
However, for awesome, engrossing, immersive sound in a portable package that's comfortable and practical enough to listen to literally all day in a variety of audiophile-hostile environments (work, Best Buy, etc) - it's hard to find an equivalent to the UE-11. I'm not saying ACS, Freq, Livewire, Sensaphonics, Westone, Future Sonics and other customs IEM won't provide the same gratification - just that I cannot possibly afford to try them all.
Custom IEMs combine many desirable performance characteristics from multiple well-known universal IEMs, while seemingly introducing few non-financial penalties (e.g. no need to deal with replacing foam tips yet customs provide isolation and comfort, both bass quantity and detail, very portable yet has a 'big' sound, etc). And you pay a premium for this.
And the process of making impressions and getting a good fit is not without it's failures. I'm lucky because I have customs-friendly ears.
Perfection is not guaranteed for the price of the UE-11, either. If you bought a Hyundai and it turns out to be a lemon, you may be more forgiving than if your Bugatti Veyron turned out to be a lemon (though if you can afford one Veyron, you can probably afford two).
Above and beyond this, each manufacturer's customs has different sound signatures, and the process becomes like choosing among different IEMs.
If you need or really want custom IEMs, then the UE-11 is worth
considering. Buying it solely for it's sonic attributes is a setup for disappointment given the cost. Few things will beat the UE-11 in sound quality per cubic inch, but many options will beat it in sound quality per dollar.