Mark, you know that there are many that just flat out say it's voodoo even though it's proven it's not. You also know that others bring up Rega how put out a 1 million dollar challenge for a blind test and when his challenge was taken he didn't agree with what a blind test is. So it's a subject that turns stupid to those that refuse to believe and those that do.
I know what you mean, and I wasn't trying to get at the heart of what is true or what isn't, as you say, even that is subjective. My only point was this never ending cable debate/discussions can really turn into noise and derail threads (like I'm doing now LOL) so I will stop after this post. My takeaway point is that there has to be a compromise solution for this. Maybe it is that those who don't believe have to suck it up, but they can argue that those who do believe can also suck it up and go discuss the topic in a dedicated forum.
I think a hybrid solution might be best for the community. I see it this way, the community is made up of many people, sometimes with competing agendas, needs etc. All contribute to the richness and diversity of use that makes for a true Internet community. For example, I respect the once cottage industry of custom cable makers who have worked their asses off to build up a business, or larger dealers such as yourself who may sell some of these products. Just because they have a commercial interest at times doesn't mean they don't really enrich the community in many ways. So I wouldn't want to see their revenue drop as they can't get word of mouth free advertising through forum posts. I also know that these people come from a genuine background of interest in this hobby and community so it is equally unfair to simply write them off as only interested in selling things. In my experience people are nicer than that, and far more complex so I certainly would never want it to seem that I want them to suffer.
I'm kind of a Ying and Yang guy, I like balance in things and as such I'm sure there is a way to find a compromise approach. I mean come on, surely even those who love cables and talking about them must be tired of it frequently in not most of the time turning into a debate? God knows I am. So how if at all can we as a community make the situation better for everybody?
I think having primary cable discussions in a dedicated forum and threads with allowing/encouraging posters to drop links in the other forums a perfectly valid hybrid approach. Here is my fictional example, lets use the thread we are in for an example:
OP: I'm really looking for a nice silver cable for my Utopia, in the past I really liked what I heard from using silver cables, but I'm not sure what would work with the Utopia. Do any of you here have a suggestion?
Reply: Hey ..... I recently tried a really nice Axios cable and I posted my impressions here [thread link] check it out if you like.
OP: Awesome, thanks I just read your post and that sounds like exactly what I'm looking for, I replied with another questions. Thanks
Problem solved, OP found his answer, Utopia thread didn't turn into a cable debate, everybody is happy.