Good review, and I can imagine it could be frustrating to have people looking at every word with a magnifying glass... but that's what I'm doing.
One thing I was really looking forward to was a sound that had walk-through 3-dimensionality on the musical instruments. Also, I really wanted a balance between relaxed and forgiving highs while maintaining excellent nuance, detail, and even some sparkle. Those are qualities I prized in my old HiFiMan RE-262's and had a fair bit of in the R2A, though the R2A sacrificed the sparkle a bit in order to get those other qualities. Based on what you've written above, I wonder if the new FLARES will keep me satisfied.
Thanks for reading and commenting!
First and foremost I’d like to emphasize that it was an early prototype that was on display, not the product that will be offered on Kickstarter. CanJam show was an opportunity for Flare Audio to interact with the community in an open environment in their home country - far from ideal to do give them a proper listen and describe them in detail. Do think of it as an introduction to the new products they have been proudly working on to share with the public. It was fun!
It was clear to me they were offering people a chance to hear the improvement and progress that they have been made in just a few months after the appearance of their first iems. They were not selling anything, no slick talk. As a seasoned backer I can only give high praises to the Flare Audio team for revealing the FLARES under these circumstances, it's exemplary to get to listen to a future KS product in this stage, not even being at beta level, a very vulnerable situation they’ve put themselves into.
The FLARES HD have made a great impression over the entire spectrum but
especially in the mid and lower range. I could give you the sweet talk here, confirming that the highs are at least as sparkling and 3D effect (I rather call ‘out of the head’ effect), but I won't. To be clear, the highs were excellent and there was sparkling, yet they weren’t on
exactly the same level as the R2Pro
at that time. Call me a nitpicker, for all I know they were doing an experiment to see how listeners would respond to a closed setting of the back venting or to a non-burned in sample? I don’t know.
My ears are by no means of the golden type, but if you would read my community profile, reading between the lines of the early impression and the final thoughts, you will notice that I do like my trebles and I said I would choose the early prototype over my beloved R2Pro. - mind you I did not compare them to the R2A (aluminum) like you seem to suggest, it was the R2Pro (titanium) so I was comparing apples with apples -
Again, on the prototype without the brain burn-in (which definitely did bloom the R2Pro!) the improvement already made, to me evidently showed the ambition Flare Audio have with these and it was more than enough to convince me of the quality of what the final product will hold, right there on the spot. That does not exclude any evolving of the sound signature from that point forward as Naomi mentioned in her notes, these guys are on a mission for sure. I’d be more than willing to part from my R2Pro now, knowing what the successor will be capable of, just send me a PM with a reasonable offer and we will work something out
The ‘Early Impression’ is what it is. Others may think from it differently and undoubtedly there will be a number of opinions on these as soon as the beta version will be send out to professional reviewers, probably well in time before the project gets funded. I hope to receive one of those as well and report back to you. Until then, I consider myself fortunate to have gotten a sneak preview/listen on the FLARES HD as for what’s to come and to do a write-up as the first of many to follow. Meanwhile I hope it will encourage you and other people with the magnifying glasses to give their feedback here for Flare Audio to read, rather than dismissing the FLARES now bluntly based on my early report on the supposed ‘lacking’ of highs. That would be frustrating and a real mistake as I feel you’re ruling out a highly potential and versatile IEM when it arrives to the market by focusing on that, not only for you but to many potential buyers too. A lot of members from this community did so with the first Kickstarter campaign, they should not make the same mistake again.