This is my first post here on head-fi. I decided to make an account and chime in, and I’m sure I’ll be posting more in the future. I’m on mobile so excuse the auto-correct and if I did something wrong.
I’ve spent quite a few hours examining and putting to the test various mp3 encoders.
I once read a page online which measured the effects mp3 compression had at different bit-rates to the noise floor of a 16-bit file as well as the removal of certain frequencies the encoder figures were not needed.
I discovered LameXP a few days ago and figured I’d look into it since it utilizes the lame 3.100.
After much experimentation; if I set the algorithm quality to highest, used V0, joint stereo, and enabled bit-rate management to 320kbps, the 16-bit dither was also retained without much loss.
Using experiments at lower bit-rates I was shocked to discover that V0 at 128k sounds better than CBR 128k. ABX tests were easy on that part.
V0 has many features that CBR does not include, such as noise shaping, and when forced to stay at one bit-rate it seems to perform better than CBR.
I never got into programming my encoders with custom commands and have always preferred using a GUI.
I still convert my lossless to 40khz sample rate with Audacity at Best Settings and back to 44.1khz to the encoder so the high frequencies past 20khz don’t weigh down the encoder and tends to even keep a shaped dither intact and mostly artifact free.
I recommend LameXP and the settings stated above if one wants to get the highest quality setting out of mp3.
(I have a lot of classical and dynamic/quiet recordings)
I don’t see the need for lossless except for archiving. I like to keep the copies in case I have to re-encode and will always consider my lossless rips to be pure gold. I love my newly encoded mp3s because of portability, compatibility, and quality.
Putting the lossless and the mp3 together while reversing the phase of one of them highlights the info removed during the encoding and luckily the difference between the encoders and encoder settings is measurable.
It was fun to examine, test, compare, measure, and figure out the highest quality mp3 encoder and settings, but I’m glad I have finally found the perfect setting and encoder..... until lame gets updated again