Hi,
I just wanted to get my personal feedback between these 2 players, Fiio X3 gen2 and Sony A20 (I tested A10, seems same to me). I don't give accurate numbers, it more my experience of user.
First, my profile : you will be able to see if what I seeked/noticed can be helpful for you or not.
I was searching a nomade player with big capacity (more than 100Go), convenient to use, and with good sound.
When I say good sound: I'm not at all a specialist, nor an amator of good sound. So to me, good sound means not crappy sound
(I used before a Creative Zen X-Fi with sony internal headphones, so no "sharp" devices).
You understand here that i'm not a musician nor a music pure lover
Just want to have good music in my ears
I mostly have MP3 320 Khz, otherwise some FLAC files. High res isn't a need to me, but I can like it
So here is MY conclusions, only relevant to me, of course.
(I'll use my best english, maybe not perfect on some terms
1/ THE DEVICE
X3ii
To me it's a very good device. Feels very well built, and without the case it's really pretty.
I like the size, even if a little too much thick...
I don't know if it's relevant, but beeing lefthanded, i like the buttons on,vol+/next,vol-/previous on the right size, when having in hand it's really convenient.
Contrary to what I read, i really like the wheel... It's accurate to me, got no problem with precision.
A20
Seems a little cheap... The front face is pretty coz in metal, but the back in plastic, makes it cheap.
And same for the 2 face button home/back, and the volume button : in plastic, sadly. The screen ? plastic ... easily scratched, put a screen protector quickly
But on other hand, it enables to get a very very light device
And that's very very convenient, my pockets are very happy
The pad on the complete bottom of the device makes it (to me) weird to handle the device while changing tracks... I feel like i'm handling the devide by the bottom edge, i feel i could let it fall. I totally get used to it thought, but I would not have designed it like that.
The headphone input at the bottom ? I don't like it at all ... it bothers me when I handle the device. Same
as above, i get used to it... but why ?
MY CONCLUSION:
X3ii more convenient, more beautiful, more solid. A20 more portable
2/ THE SOUND
I won't talk a lot about it, as I said previously i'm far to be an expert.
It seems to me than X3ii has a more clear or neutral sound, whereas A20 has a more signed sound... But it's just a feeling, whenever I use on of the 2 I enjoy the sound
And anyway, in both you can play with EQ if you want, so...
Big difference : the power ... While I feel with X3ii I can make my ears bleed (litterally maybe, never tried more than half the wheel), the A20 is very limited (european model). But in classic usage (bus, train) I never go over 17 (on 30), so if I was first afraid of this limitation, on usage it doesn't impact me. Except if you use it with external speakers I guess ?
3/ THE FIRMWARE
Just to precise, I used an Sandisk 10 C 128 Go, the same for both.
I have 11504 songs.
X3ii
I like the appearence, it's sober. Easy to navigate into with the wheel, it's clear and efficient.
In the library (by tags or by albums) you have a lot of lines on the screen, I like it to choose.
Sadly you can't navigate letter by letter to make the browsing faster, but could be bring by an update.
BUT... I experienced some little lags when navigating into library; no matters of second, but there's lag,
and it bothers me. I don't know if it vanishes with less music, or no cover, but that's annoying to me. I like the fact the player uses the files as they are, it doesn't add any files or folder structure on the sd card... And you can delete the files
Maybe that's a downside of that, the library is kinda long to be actualized (more than the A20).
Shortcut are good : let pressed the volume to go to next/previous track, let pressed back button to return to the current played song, or the home screen, ...
A20
Seems a little old fashion, but well i don't mind. Navigation with the 4 direction pad is easy, so OK.
The screen is big, but the font too, so you don't have a lots of line on the screen, you have to click a lot
to browse. Fortunately, you can navigate letters by letters, so the navigation stays convenient. I don't experience any lag while navigating, it's fluid, I like it.
BUT I don't like the device integration, it needs it's own directory structure, you loose some metadata (like sensme if the documentation is right) when you remove the sd card...
Maybe it's a upside of that, but the library is faster than on the X3ii to be actualized
A remark : damn you can't delete file !! What ??
Oh, another remark : when connecting on computer, you have to choose between internal storage and sd card storage... Sad, i would have preferred to see both at same time.
Oh, another remark : no shortcut to get back to the current play song. Let pressed the back button bring you to the home screen, not the playing screen... No very important, but it's sad for a player device.
(instead you can click option button, then click playing list or playing screen, and you get there)
MY CONCLUSION
I prefer the X3ii firmware in conception and appearance. But in practice, because of the lag mainly, I prefer the A20. (Even if you can't delete files, and it needs it's own structure directories >:[)
4/ AUTONOMY
X3ii
Well, no surprise, the A20 has a really better autonomy. But less power, less audiophile functions, I bet it has a better electronic engine, so it can be understood. The X3ii autonomy (around 10h for me) is good actually.
BUT the charging time of the X3ii is for me is too long : between 7h or 9h on USB, and 4h on sector ... To me its too long for a 11h theorical battery.
A20
To compare, the A20 charges on 4 hours on usb (didn't try it on sector yet).
MY CONCLUSION
The ration charging time/autonomy is not good to me on the X3iio... I want a travelling convenient device , and for my usage the charging time is too long for the given autonomy.
5/ CHARGING CONNEXION
X3ii
micro usb, YEAH
A20
proprietary ... Sony wants you to pay more !! shame on you
MY CONCLUSION
A20 can't win this point, proprietary is soooo lame
6/ ADDITIONAL ACCESSORIES IN PACKAGE
X3ii
Screen protectors, Yeaah
Case, Yeaah
Stickers to change aspect... What ?
coaxial converter, Yeaaah
A20
Headphones, Yeaah
No screen protectors, no case, daaaaaaammit
MY CONCLUSSION
X3ii has a better package, except for the lacke of headphones, it's complete.
7/ OTHERS FEATURES
Just to know, some of users (maybe most of them) would say "whaaat ? this function just in the feature section ?!" ... Yes, sorry, just a review for my usages
X3ii
- Line output & coaxial : sounds very nicely, with good power when I used it on my old Marantz ampli ... Love it
- OTG : didn't use it, but seems to be VERY COOL for some audiophiles, so CHECK FOR IT
- DAC usage : same as above, CHECK FOR IT
A20
- Bluetooth : convenient to me, for some headphones, or on the car, or on portative speakers (didn't try it thought, wonder about the sound power)
- Radio FM : very convenient to me too, for the football match like world cup, when i'm stuck at work or transport
- Video : useless
- Picture : useless
- SensMe : seems nice, but long to build, unless you use MediaGo software on PC ... Don't like to use third app, eew
- Karaoke mode, tempo change, etc etc ... So many useless functions
- Noise Cancelling : didn't try it, coz I have a Bose with it's own NC. But can be convenient, coz with 1 headphone you can have
NC or not, since it can be disabled in menu
Of course if you buy a compatible sony headphone, business :/
8/ MY CHOICE
So a mix of those 2 devices would be AWESOME ! But it's doesn't exist (or I don't know it), so I had to choose depending my priorities...
I ended with the A20 : autonomy & charging time, fluidity while browsing, bluetooth, size & weight
But it means i have to stick with cheap appearance, old fashion interface, the proprietary plug, plenty useless fonctions, less good ergonomy
and weak power.
And I have to buy another connexion cable, just in case I loose mine, because 'im not sure to find someone with same cable quickly ...
The A20 fits more my needs than X3ii, but it's expensive for what it provides, especially if you count an additioanal cable, a case and a screen protector. I can afford it so I did it, but would not recommand it if you search a good quality/price ratio (A10 is better now since cheaper, if you're not interested
in SONY numeric NC and EQ on high res file).
Maybe it can help some of you to decide, otherwise i just lose some minutes, no harm done