KopaneDePooj
Headphoneus Supremus
Matter so much. It's matter of trust. I definitely don't trust reviews who don't have explicit disclosure policy.
Who knows that a review sacrifice other people to pursue his own personal benefit? You never know.
To protect this hobby and community, I vehemently argue that people must know who can be trusted. Disclosure policy is a just starting point.
If you have nothing to hide, just disclose it.
To each his own, but I try to know and form my opinion about a reviewer as a person by reading or watching a few of his reviews. That values to me more than a phrase like: "This item was given to to me free, in exchange of my honest and unbiased review". A phrase like that won't make me trust a reviewer more. Also in this hobby you better not blindly "trust" that what you read in a review will work for you. You try to read between the lines and try to extract some cues that will help you know if the item will match YOUR preferences. I learned that the hard way. "This sounds good", "This is the best", all ended up for sale too many times. So now I'm circumspect about any review "trusted" or not, and try to sample before buying as much as I can.