I have three different Westone custom ER-4 molds made from the same set of impressions.
Set #1: W-1 soft silicone. Comfortable, but the lowest-fi of the bunch. Some bass energy is clearly being absorbed into the softness of the material, and overall clarity suffers. (They're still Etys and they still are remarkably clear, but they're down a bit from what they can be.)
Set #2: OtoBlast clear silicone with smooth ("water-clear") finish. Excellent sound, but the silicone is quite "grippy" and takes a fair amount of work to insert even when it's lubed up with some OtoEase.
Set #3: Otoblast clear silicone with matte finish. Same sound as the smooth finish, but the insertion problem goes away. My favorite. May sacrifice a small amount of isolation compared to the others - I kind of think so, but am not 100% sure.
I find the firm and soft silicones equally comfortable.
Set #1: W-1 soft silicone. Comfortable, but the lowest-fi of the bunch. Some bass energy is clearly being absorbed into the softness of the material, and overall clarity suffers. (They're still Etys and they still are remarkably clear, but they're down a bit from what they can be.)
Set #2: OtoBlast clear silicone with smooth ("water-clear") finish. Excellent sound, but the silicone is quite "grippy" and takes a fair amount of work to insert even when it's lubed up with some OtoEase.
Set #3: Otoblast clear silicone with matte finish. Same sound as the smooth finish, but the insertion problem goes away. My favorite. May sacrifice a small amount of isolation compared to the others - I kind of think so, but am not 100% sure.
I find the firm and soft silicones equally comfortable.