I propose adopting a new standard to
replace S/PDIF: digital audio over TCP/IP!
- Error correction. Finally end the debate on jitter, reflections, and the 75 ohm business.
- Ethernet cable is well understood, affordable, and reliable.
- Connect both your desktop PC and your laptop to the same DAC with a router.
- You can even plug your DAC into a wireless router. They say the best cable is no cable.
- Directly play music from an iPhone to the DAC over wifi.
- Stream music from your home directly to your DAC at the office.
Sure, TPC/IP is not 100% reliable (but it's close) when used over the internet due to the sheer amount of traffic out there, but it is still a gajillion times better than if the internet was built on S/PDIF. "You say the online banking doesn't work? Try a glass toslink cable instead." *shudder* If you're concerned about lag and bandwidth congestion, then just use a separate LAN for your audio.
Internally, most if not all DACs use the I2S format for the actual DAC chip. It is the S/PDIF stage that suffers from jitter. The I2S part does not have such problems, but it is only suited for the short distances like those on the circuit board. So as an interim solution, we could have a TCP/IP to I2S transport to still continue to use some of the current crop of DACs. Some current DACs can input I2S, and many others can be modded for that.
Who's with me? Or is this a crazy idea?