Hahaha
Yes, Regal, I agree on that. Not even in English it seems clear to me what musical should mean. I will start my Phd here... (in any case it is easier than the one I try to finish in the "real world"!)
"Musical" is a nice word, used by any of us so called "audiophiles" just in the way each one likes. According to
THIS definition, an audiophile is more in love with the engineering than with the music. So how should "we" audio-gear-o-philes know, what the term "musical" means...?
In any case, what I expect from my gear is to make canned music sound as fresh as possible. Any flavor should be a flavor of the music itself, not of the gear. However, one thing is clear: It is all just an illusion. What I want is to get the illusion of live music. So, when talking about all this electronic stuff used to give the live feeling back to conserved music, "musical" would mean for me exactly the same as "neutral". However, we newer know, how the "real" sound was like, before it got canned... so the PhD turns out to be purely speculative...
If that's all there is, let's just enjoy the music - and for those, who are more in love with the technical stuff than with the music, enjoy the gadgets
. I'll keep up listening and trying to open up my heart for this new way, music comes into my living room with the Re 9... For now it gives me a distant feeling.
Its like the feeling when you are about to enter a room where somebody is playing music: This wish to come closer. It is a nice feeling though, and it is pretty realistic with the Re 9, but the feeling to be "in" the room would be more desirable for me. Listening to my turntable, I can get such a feeling of being really just part of it. For moments, I can get the illusion of a direct proximity without anything in between, and I like it. It is personal taste however... This is, when I can get strong emotions even from conserved music. Perhaps the sound of the Re9 will come closer over time.