CLOSED
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jun 14, 2021 at 5:05 PM Post #63 of 313
UPDATE: 15 June 2021
Earlier today I conducted some tests on the power differences between my LG V35 phone and a Xiaomi Mi 9t. I had some suspicion that my V35 while working fine on all the dongles, seems to exhibit some anomalies which gave me concerns when hosting some of the latest model DAC chips. And true enough, I re-run the test for Questyle M12 and I was greeted with improved presentation now that it is powered properly. So with this taken into consideration, I am already switching to Mi 9t to rerun the tests especially for the 4 1/2 stars and 5 Star dongles.

I have already revised my personal grading and rating for the M12 on the first page. It deserve a 98/100 rating now. Which means with all the strength exhibited and with the cons considered, it is definitely a stellar unit beyond any doubt. All the 5 stars performers have their own unique way of attaining the above 95 points grade. Of which I have written as concisely as possible and will continue to refine them as I conduct more re-tests
 
Jun 15, 2021 at 11:54 AM Post #68 of 313
Hidizs S9 Pro ($119.00)
DAC Chip:
ESS ES9038Q2M (Single)
PCM 32bit - 768khz DSD512, SNR: -120dB, Power: 200mW 32Ω, Type-C Female, 2.5mm BAL & 3.5mm SE (Microphone: No), Aluminum/Glass Chassis​
🟢Strengths:
  • Energetic neutral and natural airy smooth timbre, faithfully uncolored
  • Refined dynamics with well matured vibrancy
  • Reference grade coherence with pristine clarity and great transparency
  • Slightly spaced out Mids with rich textures and definition, realistic Male/Female vocals
  • Crisp smooth Treble with matured finesse, depth, extension, and textures
  • Richly textured Mid-Bass with commanding vibe and smooth decay
  • Deep, richly textured Sub-Bass with realistic decay
  • Excellent details retrieval, Macro and Micro. Smoothly nuanced
  • Realistic and crisp guitar, piano, cello, and bass guitar tones
  • Lively sounding percussions (chimes, bells) and realistic drums and taps
  • Wide soundstage with great depth and spacing.
  • Reference grade imaging, razor sharp precision with holographic spatial staging
  • Reference grade speed and transients handling, no hint of congestion
  • Zero floor noises with black background
  • Free of any coarseness or grainy edges overall
  • Immensely powerful SE and BAL output with commanding drive
  • Absolutely gorgeous sounding paired with literally anything.
🔴Weaknesses:
  • Sub-Bass seismic decay could be a little bit crisper
  • No hardware volume adjuster
  • Rare occasions may exhibit Treble sheen that can be perceived as peaky (on an already very resolving IEMs/Headphones)
VERDICT:
Hidizs S9 Pro
. The successor for the already great S9 is here. Hidizs intended for this S9 Pro to excel beyond S9 and they holistically succeeded in achieving it. The way they tuned and implemented ES9038Q2M for S9 Pro is the most refined example I have heard yet – considering I am very well versed with ES9038Q2M devices be it a DAP, Laptop DAC or other Dongles, S9 Pro took the crown. Credit must be given to Hidizs for such finesse in the way they tuned S9 Pro that it is so well balanced between technicality and musicality. This smoothness is a rarity among the typically bright natured ESS. S9 Pro very deftly picks up every detail without reservation, the better your IEMs/HPs resolves, the more details being presented. There’s beautiful balance of crispiness and airiness between layers which translates into soothing sonic pleasure. Bass presentation is as meaty as it gets with refined textures and tight control. It was a pain for me to identify and nit-pick for any weaknesses and all that I could muster is to say this S9 Pro can exhibit some Treble sheen on some recordings that would be regarded as shouty – and even that it would still not count as sibilant.

I just can’t resist myself from comparing this beautiful S9 Pro against my No.1 favorite, the Ovidius B1. And here’s what I found after almost 3 hours of A/B using all four of my favorite IEMs (Shure KSE1500, ER4SR, ER2XR and Heart Mirror):
  1. B1 have slightly more forward oriented presentation (that AKM intimacy if you will), S9 Pro a step back
  2. B1 slightly more rounded polished edged while S9 Pro crispy smooth edged
  3. B1 still a bit more brutally transparent while S9 Pro a bit more forgiving on the sources
Yes, it was painful for me to compare these two because they are both exceedingly stellar that even small differences usually meant they are just exhibiting their mild differences – not a question of which one is better over the other, it’s about which one appease to your taste better. Pick your poison!
Hidizs S9 Pro effortlessly climbs into the 5 Stars group without even blinking.

OVERALL RATING: 98/100
Recommended Pairing:
Best synergy with technically competent IEMs and Headphones.
20210613_210028_HDR.jpg
_________________________________________________
*Reserved*
PS:
I will not be testing L&P W2 because the power requirement is not suitable for USB 2.0 found on most Android Phones or even iPhones
By analysis would you consider the brightest S9 Pro to be analytical and the hottest and most musical B1?
 
Jun 15, 2021 at 1:03 PM Post #70 of 313
I have s9 akm and I think it's perfect, slightly warm and smooth, I'm afraid to upgrade to s9 pro and be too bright.
Too bright is not how I would describe S9 Pro. As I noted in my impressions, the tuning of the ES9038Q2M for this unit is one of the most matured implementation so far. It is sparkly and airy while keeping smoothness. I know when the sound gets shouty or sibilant because my N6ii E02 and Topping D10s which uses the same DAC chips would do that - now that's too bright. The best part, S9 Pro is faithfully smooth and slightly warm inline with the original S9 signature. I have both and I know this for a fact
 
Jun 15, 2021 at 1:05 PM Post #71 of 313
Too bright is not how I would describe S9 Pro. As I noted in my impressions, the tuning of the ES9038Q2M for this unit is one of the most matured implementation so far. It is sparkly and airy while keeping smoothness. I know when the sound gets shouty or sibilant because my N6ii E02 and Topping D10s which uses the same DAC chips would do that - now that's too bright. The best part, S9 Pro is faithfully smooth and slightly warm inline with the original S9 signature. I have both and I know this for a fact
Eagerly awaiting your review of the E1DAs, Andy. Holding off my purchase of the S9 Pro until then. Thanks for doing this.
 
Jun 15, 2021 at 2:21 PM Post #72 of 313
Too bright is not how I would describe S9 Pro. As I noted in my impressions, the tuning of the ES9038Q2M for this unit is one of the most matured implementation so far. It is sparkly and airy while keeping smoothness. I know when the sound gets shouty or sibilant because my N6ii E02 and Topping D10s which uses the same DAC chips would do that - now that's too bright. The best part, S9 Pro is faithfully smooth and slightly warm inline with the original S9 signature. I have both and I know this for a fact
Regarding the bass, does the original S9 have a greater amount and impact of bass compared to the s9 pro, or is it the other way around?
 
Jun 15, 2021 at 2:30 PM Post #74 of 313
I also heard that the S9 Pro has thinner mids than the original
Not thinner mids, if you read my impressions again, ESS has that one step back mids compared to most AKM based DACs, a matter of saying AKM DACs a bit for forward intimate and the ESS just not as close. Texture wise they are similar. As for bass, Hidizs somehow managed to tune both S9 and S9 PRO with similar tight, fast and punchy bass with equal dynamics and body weight
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top