AussieMick
500+ Head-Fier
Which is why it’s so important to keep weeding, right? Getting the noise floor ever lower reveals more and more low level detail. It becomes extremely important to some listeners, which is why they invest power distribution and regeneration, cables with good grounding, grounding boxes and the like, cables with good resistance to mechanical noise, devices to isolate gear from vibration, devices to drain away vibration created within gear, room treatments…and that’s all on the analogue side. Then there are people who invest heavily in the digital dude with USB reclockers, Ethernet switches, optical isolators, digital cables with better noise rejection…the list goes on.Looked at another way, there is no electrical signal that can be absolutely identified as "noise." "Noise" is just a way to describe any electrical signal added to the original signal that the end-user doesn't want (as opposed to "distortion" which is an alteration of the signal).
"Noise" is like the word "weed." There is no actual plant that is identifiable as a "weed." A "weed" is just a catchall term for any plant you don't want in your garden. Just like your garden doesn't care about the difference between a "vegetable" and a "weed," electronics don't care about the difference between "signal" and "noise." They just do their job, which is to conduct electrical currents. Designers do their darnedest to keep signal and noise separate, but electronic components could give a giant F. They just want to conduct.
One of the problems we have in discussing all of this is where people live. If you live on the seventh floor of an old walk-up in Hoboken, surrounded by a hundred people all using blenders and refrigerators and vacuum cleaners and microwaves and multiple wifi and Bluetooth devices, these things will matter more to you than if you live in a rural area without as much interference (although it’s still there in lesser amounts). So one person trying a given device might find it very influential, while another hears nothing, then the two jump on a forum to compare experiences and it tends to go downhill from there.
It tends to make my personal experiences and your personal experiences incredibly relevant to ourselves, but not so much to people with different circumstances. It’s why I like to listen to those who are bringing product to market and what those designers (not marketing departments) have to say about “electrical noise” as it pertains to “hifi systems”, as we don’t listen to any one element on its own.
I agree with you 100% about your weed analogy. I’d like to use that, if you don’t mind.