Triode User
Member of the Trade: WAVE High Fidelity
A simple question and hopefully with a simple answer for a simple person like me please.
I normally use an Auralic streamer to output to my Dave but BBC R3 has a trial service for 6 months outputting FLAC and this is only available via the Firefox browser and not via the Auralic.
From the Beeb website.
"For the duration of the pilot we are providing a simulcast of Radio 3’s live output compressed using FLAC, so it sounds every bit (no pun intended!) as good as when it left us.
How does it work?
We’re using FLAC and MPEG-DASH to deliver losslessly-compressed audio to your browser.
Because the specification for how to do this is so new, only Firefox (51 or greater) on desktop is able to play our stream, but in time we hope other browsers, mobile devices and internet radio manufacturers will follow suit, and we are actively engaging with vendors to make this happen.
Any challenges and what were the solutions?
The main challenge was finding a standards-based approach to delivering lossless audio to the browser. Following discussions with technology partners such as internet radio vendors, it was clear that FLAC would be the preferred compression method, but, at the time, there was no specification describing carriage of FLAC in MP4 for MPEG-DASH.
During discussions around other technologies, Mozilla and the Xiph.org Foundation offered to standardise encapsulation in MP4, and this was published on 1st January 2017. Firefox support was implemented ahead of this date, and R&D have built a prototype production workflow based on this specification."
So, for the first time I have therefore been using my iMac's digital output to the Dave.
And here's the simple question. In Audio MIDI Setup, which output frequency should I select to go to the Dave? 44 kHz through to 768 kHz all work, are recognised by the Dave and show up on the Dave display with the correct frequency (32 kHz doesn't, or at least it is broken up and distorted).
I have had a play, as you do, and to my ears and with speech the higher output frequencies sound slightly 'overbright' or even slightly sibilant. Maybe due to the mac being unsuccessful in it's attempt to upsample?
So, what is the answer to life, the universe, everything and also what is the correct output frequency to the Dave?
42?

I normally use an Auralic streamer to output to my Dave but BBC R3 has a trial service for 6 months outputting FLAC and this is only available via the Firefox browser and not via the Auralic.
From the Beeb website.
"For the duration of the pilot we are providing a simulcast of Radio 3’s live output compressed using FLAC, so it sounds every bit (no pun intended!) as good as when it left us.
How does it work?
We’re using FLAC and MPEG-DASH to deliver losslessly-compressed audio to your browser.
Because the specification for how to do this is so new, only Firefox (51 or greater) on desktop is able to play our stream, but in time we hope other browsers, mobile devices and internet radio manufacturers will follow suit, and we are actively engaging with vendors to make this happen.
Any challenges and what were the solutions?
The main challenge was finding a standards-based approach to delivering lossless audio to the browser. Following discussions with technology partners such as internet radio vendors, it was clear that FLAC would be the preferred compression method, but, at the time, there was no specification describing carriage of FLAC in MP4 for MPEG-DASH.
During discussions around other technologies, Mozilla and the Xiph.org Foundation offered to standardise encapsulation in MP4, and this was published on 1st January 2017. Firefox support was implemented ahead of this date, and R&D have built a prototype production workflow based on this specification."
So, for the first time I have therefore been using my iMac's digital output to the Dave.
And here's the simple question. In Audio MIDI Setup, which output frequency should I select to go to the Dave? 44 kHz through to 768 kHz all work, are recognised by the Dave and show up on the Dave display with the correct frequency (32 kHz doesn't, or at least it is broken up and distorted).
I have had a play, as you do, and to my ears and with speech the higher output frequencies sound slightly 'overbright' or even slightly sibilant. Maybe due to the mac being unsuccessful in it's attempt to upsample?
So, what is the answer to life, the universe, everything and also what is the correct output frequency to the Dave?
42?