How was the turnout this year (members not vendors)? It seems it was much lower than previous years. I think NYC is a great spot to hold it next year. Chicago has been mentioned and I think it would be a crackin awesome city to visit but NYC along with the wonderful members who have hosted meets before, seems to be a very logical spot. It also helps that the member turnout is much larger in NYC and with the growth in popularity, I can't see there being a decrease in vendors attending.
NYC is also great for a good bunch of us Canucks. I'd wager 80% of the Canadians on this forum are from Ontario and Quebec, specifically Toronto east to Montreal. Because of this, you get a strong faction from up North plus the heaps of Head-fiers from the East coast and onward north to Chicago. Yes there are plenty who fly out from the West Coast, but no doubt, most attending tend to stay local.
My vote, NYC! Oh, and I can actually attend next year if it is in NYC (or Chicago for that matter).