Originally Posted by Lamprologus /img/forum/go_quote.gif
I made a comparison today of D1000 and ES7, it seems as D1000 don't change much with 50+ hours of use.
Source is an old Harman Kardon CD player, HD7600, dating back to approx. 1991. It's slightly on the warm side of neutral and is not the best for creating a proper soundstage, but it's fairly dynamic. My impression is that it compares quite favourably to brand new CD players of today in the lower to mid price range. Amps are the Headfive and Harmony Design Ear 90.
For starters, D1000 is more comfortable than ES7. It seems the D1000 has at least great comfort in common with it's big brothers, the D2K and D5K. I don't think ES7 is uncomfortable but D1000 is basically the definition of comfortable. My wife agrees on this point as well.
When it comes to sound, my early impressions still hold. ES7 is more forward and with more bass quantity while D1000 is more laid back but also brighter sounding (not sure if I mistake thin for bright). The D1000 has more air but has less impact. Soft versus sharp. K701 versus Grado. Well, not really but maybe you get my point?
I may be wrong but I consider the ES7 to have a forward midrange and a rather well behaved top end. Bottom end was rather boomy to start with but it seems to settle nicely. D1000 is more neutral I would say, but the mids may be slightly recessed, at least to my ears. Comparing to how my speakers sound (B&W 803S, PMC FB1+, PMC DB1), the ES7 is much closer to these.
The song Don't get me wrong (on the re-issue of the Pretenders:Get close), sound thin and unemotional through the D1000. ES7 manages to capture the drive and emotion of the song. This difference was maintained, more or less, for all recordings I tried, ranging from classic rock/pop/blues to modern rock/pop (Neil Young, Sherman Robertson, Pretenders, Sahara Hotnights, Natalie Cole, Oh Laura) . Needless to say, I preferred the ES7 for this kind of music.
I also tried some classical music, GEMINIANI: Concerti Grossi on Harmonia Mundi, which benefited from the wider soundstage and more airy presentation of the D1000. For this recording I actually preferred D1000 over the ES7.
Overall, I prefer the ES7 over the D1000. It's not that the D1000 is bad, quite the contrary. D1000 has a lot that I like, I prefer it to my HD25-1 for instance. It's just that for me, and the music I listen to the most, D1000 is a little too soft and thin sounding compared to the ES7.
I have the D2000 on order as well, I hope the bigger brother improves on more than the bass .....
|