IEMCrazy
Longwindeus Supremus
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2012
- Posts
- 1,506
- Likes
- 67
Quote:
It comes back to the old "did I buy the disc, or did I buy a license" debate where DRM-loving publishers want to eat their cake and have it too. If you own the disc, then it is your right to sell that disc as property. If you own a license, then it is your right copy and transfer that license to as many devices as possible so long as you're using only one license at a time and do not transfer it. While they argue about you buying the disc or buying a license what they really provide you is a lease. But "lease" doesn't sell well in marketing speak so they try to pretend it's something else.
Quote:
True enough, but to preserve an SACD you need only keep it in a box and not physically damage it. My SACD's don't randomly depolarize and refuse to boot, or blow all backups at once in a serious power supply problem
Trouble is while buying digital may be arguably cheaper (or more expensive!) backing up digital data is far more expensive and power hungry than backing up physical content. With physical you simply must not physically damage it. With digital, no amount of redundant storage is safe enough. I come close to good backups. A fileserver running a RAID array, plus the copy on the dedicated music server, then dual backups of the main server. It's as safe as one can get outside a datacenter, and I'm not personally worried about it. But that kind of backups for normal people comes at way too substantial an expense and cost in electricity. I needed it for things beyond audio. Joe User will have a hard time justifying the costs of servers and operation (and of course redundant power!) to keep their music from getting lost. I don't blame HDTracks, but I also don't blame anyone who takes issue with that policy and refuses to support them because of it too.
I agree: If you don't like the price, no need to buy there, plenty of other vendors out there. Right now they offer what I need, the only way to get 24 bit for my Squeezebox rig, and they're doing it at an almost palatable price. It's within a dollar or two of what I used to pay Telarc for SACDs back when they sold them. I just wish they'd update their weekly sales more. It's been the same list for three weeks and counting. I like buying up the entire page of Weekly Sales when it's different....I can justify those prices far more easily
True. At least you can play them offline except there's that one company, EA maybe?, that's changing that. What's messed up is buying a disc that activates with Steam, preventing its resale (even though you aren't really supposed to re-sell PC stuff since it can just be ripped and stored, and it still has a license key I guess but still kinda messed up). Smart idea to prevent piracy, but not very nice
It comes back to the old "did I buy the disc, or did I buy a license" debate where DRM-loving publishers want to eat their cake and have it too. If you own the disc, then it is your right to sell that disc as property. If you own a license, then it is your right copy and transfer that license to as many devices as possible so long as you're using only one license at a time and do not transfer it. While they argue about you buying the disc or buying a license what they really provide you is a lease. But "lease" doesn't sell well in marketing speak so they try to pretend it's something else.
Quote:
If you lose your SACD, the shop wont give you a replacement either. As for "overcharging" -- if the price isn't good for you, don't buy from them. Not to mention, there are quite a few SACDs now that cost over $100, sometimes $250 or more because Sony stopped making them, so I have to disagree with your argument.
True enough, but to preserve an SACD you need only keep it in a box and not physically damage it. My SACD's don't randomly depolarize and refuse to boot, or blow all backups at once in a serious power supply problem
I agree: If you don't like the price, no need to buy there, plenty of other vendors out there. Right now they offer what I need, the only way to get 24 bit for my Squeezebox rig, and they're doing it at an almost palatable price. It's within a dollar or two of what I used to pay Telarc for SACDs back when they sold them. I just wish they'd update their weekly sales more. It's been the same list for three weeks and counting. I like buying up the entire page of Weekly Sales when it's different....I can justify those prices far more easily