Quote:
Congratulations on your graduation today vwinter!
+1! Now go onto greatness!
Quote:
IIRC, muppet said that the sa5 could do better in most cases. The ma900 also does better in all/most cases except build.
I generally prefer my MA900 but the SA5000 has a special sound to it that can be quite chilling...
/////////
So here are my very early impressions of the Mirosoft Surface Pro, which I got to replace a MacBook Air / Wacom Tablet / Nexus 7...
Firstly it's obvious that the device isn't great as a tablet. It's a bit too thick and a bit too heavy to really be used comfortably. Compared to a little notebook like my trusty 3 year old MacBook Air it is quite a densely packed power house - smaller and lighter with some fast hardware internals.
One thing to note though is that the Surface Pro's weight distribution is very different from a laptop. In a laptop the weight is divided between the screen and the keyboard / internals whereas the Surface Pro is a slab with an (optional) light cover / keyboard attached. It can be a little awkward to position on any surface which isn't completely flat, so using on your lap can be tricky. Surprisingly though I do a lot of web browsing just lying down / sitting inin bed and the Surface Pro is quite nice for that.
The touch / type cover is very cool, although I had a small hiccup where the thing stopped functioning for a while. It seems to be working fine now after installing mysterious firmware / software updates (I don't know if they have anything to do with the type cover) so I'll watch it for the next few days to see if it happens again. I'm typing on the type cover right now and while it still doesn't have as nice a keyboard feel as the MacBook Air it's very passable. The trackpad on the type cover is a different story - it's very small and not terribly accurate.
That is okay though because the combination of touch / keyboard / trackpad / stylus controls actually feels incredibly intuitive. I find myself quite easily just switching between all four controls naturally.
The stylus is by far the most important aspect of the Surface Pro and why I got it. And it's fantastic. The digitizer is by Wacom, supports pressure sensitivity and feels incredibly smooth and precise. One caveat: out of the box the digitizer was not completely accurate and was badly mapped by more than a few pixels, especially to screen corners. This was okay in the Not-Metro interface but for some programs where the UI elements are tiny on a 1080P screen (ie: Photoshop) this essentially rendered the stylus unusable. The default calibration routine for the digitizer uses 16 points of reference which seemingly was not enough to get an accurate mapping. I ended up finding a posting online that detailed how to run the calibration through a 200+ point routine, which was a chore to do (you have to tap on the screen 200 times on different points on a grid) but now the digitizer is accurate within a few pixels.
Because the digitizer supports pressure sensitivity the Surface Pro essentially becomes a very cheap Wacom Cintiq with a whole computer and battery in one. This really is the killer app of the Surface Pro. I've tried just doing a little sketching on Autodesk Sketchbook on the Surface and it's great fun. I haven't yet tried photo editing on the Pro but again this seems like it would be a good usage scenario - though it will probably be better once Adobe updates the Photoshop UI to work better with touch controls.
The way handwriting recognition works on Windows 8 is also deeply, deeply impressive and intuitive. Not that it doesn't make mistakes, but the system makes it very easy to correct them. While it still isn't nearly as fast as a physical keyboard this is the first time I've thought of handwriting recognition as a valid alternative to an on-screen keyboard.
As for Windows 8, I haven't used a Windows machine in 6+ years and I found a lot of the interface quite confusing - especially the division between Metro and Desktop versions of apps. Once it's all set up the way you want it though it actually works quite well, taking some clever elements from smartphone design that work really well on a touch interface. I'm actually really impressed by how personal Windows 8 feels - how you can kind of really make it your own in terms of the arrangement of the UI and the way it looks and feels. OSX actually feels a little bland in comparison, which is something I never thought I would say.
It's great that the Surface Pro supports full desktop class applications and in that sense the Surface Pro is the first tablet I have ever considered useful as opposed to some passive content creation device.
But herein lies the rub. It seems like all the tablet features the Surface Pro supports, a tablet could do better, and all the laptop features the Surface Pro supports, a laptop supports better. battery life isn't all crash hot but at 4-5 hours it's better than the old battery in my MBA... lt also gets quite warm to the touch. I feel like the fan profile could be more aggressive.
So you have to either really have to find the size and weight appealing, or have a very good idea of what you want to do with the stylus. In that sense the Surface Pro is a $1000 magic sketchbook. Do not get the Surface Pro if you cannot think how the stylus would be useful to you.
I don't know if I will keep this machine - I'll have a better idea when the window of opportunity starts closing to return it - but right now I'm sitting in a waiting room typing out these impressions and I really quite like it. I'm really looking forward to seeing the kinds of things I can actually do or create with the stylus.
I think that this is something that artists / designers should take a closer look at.