for those on the fence about the HD800 Vs HD800S
Dec 31, 2022 at 12:23 AM Thread Starter Post #1 of 49

mangakaninja2

New Head-Fier
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Posts
10
Likes
11
Location
japan
(warning, some prefer the 800S some prefer the 800, there is no wrong answer and this is just my opinion and my ears, take with a grain of salt)

I did it! i purchased an HD800, making me an owner of both the HD800s and the HD800!
sold all my other cans and will not be selling either HD800 can. that's right im keeping them both, read on

I have owned at one point the following cans:
HD598, HD650, DT880, AKG702,SRH1840, T90, T1(1st) and found my sweet spot with the HD800s i bought last year. (SN 46xxx made in Ireland)

I listen mostly to Orchestral tracks, movie/anime/tv soundtracks, soothing vocals and quiet recordings.
(from Dvorak to Ryuichi Sakamoto and henry lai, I enjoy a wide collection amassed over the years) this will be a primitive comparative review of the HD800 models, i will not dissect or pretend to be well versed in distinguishing all the frequency bands from one another, rather this is more of a general impression opinion piece.

0.jpg
0 - Copy.jpg



The HD800S blew me away with its presentation and epic stage, but after reading online too much i was left feeling: am i missing out? as chuckolatte ( a youtube reviewer) pointed out that the soundstage was reduced in the HD800s, my curiosity got the better of me and i began stalking the used market for a deal. After all Senny claim themselves that the hd800s is not an upgrade but a side-grade, a different take on their amazing hd800 hollow ring transducer.

found myself a pre-loved HD800 (s/n 38xxx )
after hooking it up to my Topping A30pro and Xduoo Ta26 for extensive listening, i can say it was the right call.


On first blood the I would be lying if i said i was impressed or wowed. honestly they sounded pretty much the same.lol
It's only upon further listening and A/B swapping the HD800S with the OG model that things took a turn... the different tuning was now unveiling itself to me and as I became conscious as to what to look for , it became strikingly apparent! the dryness, the exquisite tonal balance all around, the extension! wow. just wow. Upon first impression I would never thought they were so different! The Mids are one of the first thing one would notice. Any A/Bing these two Goliath is kind of wacky because the HD800 makes the HD800S sound Bloated in the vocal region. Not in a bad way, but not in a great way either. This feels like a compromise Senny took in order to please more listeners/customers and it can go either way depending on your playlist really. Maybe they realized that most of their customers weren't Classical aficionados and that Kpop had taken its toll on the IQ of audiophiles? how would i know.


The soundstage in the HD800S is wide and recessed in the corners around you, I now understand what chuckolatte said in one of his many comparison vids ( eg: )
The Sounds on the HD800 OG model comes from a little further away from your head and fades out in a seemingly endless fashion. It's hard to make out the limits of the stage, It is truly the biggest and most airy presentation out there. all my beloved soundtracks benefit from this immensely as I now tear up to grander than life 住友紀人's Thermae Romae's 恵みの湯. Dear god I could almost make out the faces of the angels coming for me.

Zimmy's The Lion king Orchestra suite is just more effortless and majestic as well. the Mids are not shoved in my face at the expense of everything else. There is respect for each other tonalities. No contest within the spectrum, there is harmony and peace.

The driver is not slouch on attack either, 2 steps from hell's Run Free will give any SS amp a good run for its money i think. Not that my A30 pro can't handle it, although it sounds punchier on high gain, the pot doesn't allow for a comfy listening volume there, so its either medium gain with close to channel imbalance or low gain.


One of the defining Features of the HD800S that sold a lot of people was the added Bass and warmth. I can confirm the HD800S is bass heavy, in fact it had too much bass presence in some of my more delicate tracks, causing a loss of focus on the main instruments. the OG HD800 fix this for me perfectly. Not only is the bass more laid back, there is also LESS DISTORTION in the bass, before owning an OG HD800 i`d never thought id be able to hear it but A/B testing it makes it PLAIN OBVIOUS. the HD800S is very distorted in the bass region, not only that but Senny boosted the whole region forward as well making it no so subtle upon swapping.
Phil Collins's One Family (tarzan soundtrack) has those very very low thumps starting around the 2:28 mark, the HD800s doesn't and is not able to hit as deep and with as much impact as the OG HD800. This is something you need to experience to understand but there is a cleanliness/ finesse to the OG HD800 that the HD800S lost in its tuning.


Treble is on the bright side with the OG. I'm going to be honest here and say that I prefer the HD800S's treble, but it's only by a hair and only because it's slightly brighter than the HD800S's darker tuning. That said, while looking for siblance, none was found, which is a relief as that's what made me part with the T1 and T90. Both of those being brighter than the HD800 to begin with. The beyerdynamic cans fatigued my ears like nothing else, and this could have been a concern for the OG HD800 but it is not!
Just like the HD800S the HD800 treble isn't forced, it sparkles, and there is a sense of dryness and airiness that one would be hard pressed to match. the HD800S just turns the treble down to 90% on the driver. Both offer exquisite presentation here and it comes down to preference really. 40% of my library will benefit from the extra dryness of the HD800 OG and the rest will sound better and more laid back with the HD800S treble.

That's it folks, I'm not going to sit here and pretend I'm the last word on those two amazing headphones, my journey is at an end and it's been a fun one. Never thought I'd be able to afford an HD800 one day, yet alone own 2 at once.

TLDR
Both are AMAZING headphones in my honest opinion, the HD800S tuning with its forward Mids makes it a more straightforward upgrade from the HD600 line. I believe Senny was out to please more people with its 800S tuning. You do get a more mainstream, digestible sound that will please most out there. What was sacrificed to create a more all rounded headphone in the process was the Lightning in a bottle that is the HD800. Calling the OG model an all-rounder is more of a stretch than its little brother, but in not doing so the HD800 OG is also more impressive at where it excels.

For vocals, Jazz, Louis Armstrong, 80's playlist, Santana, and any hybrid classical like Hiroyuki Sawano, I'd use my HD800S.
For everything else ( that being mostly classical, Joe Hisaishi, Orchestra Symphonic suites etc..) I'd use my HD800.

Disclaimer Both My HD800 OG 's S/N and my HD800S being recent, the 6k peak may be slightly differently tuned than yours, and i didn't feel the need to mod any headphone and ruin its beautiful tuning in the process. The newer HD800S (Ireland) in particular uses a newer process and has apparently slightly more bass than the previous HD800S. The above words are my opinion and mine only, feel free to be offended at your own leisure. discussion is welcomed!

bellow my foobar setup and my wallpaper...
Untiftled.png
0.png


 
Last edited:
Dec 31, 2022 at 8:36 PM Post #2 of 49
Treble is on the bright side with the OG. I'm going to be honest here and say that I prefer the HD800S's treble, but it's only by a hair and only because it's slightly brighter than the HD800S's darker tuning.
Take a look at SDR mod for HD800, might make you like HD800 tuning even more, definitely kills that treble spike, and it's totally reversible if it's not your cup of tea.
Tyll's review.
 
Jan 2, 2023 at 9:09 AM Post #4 of 49
Hmmm, the listed cans you owned as reference are sadly not that impressive in comparison to the HD800(S).
I can confirm the HD800S is bass heavy
Excuse me WHAT?
HD800S tuning with its forward Mids
Just no.

Do you mean in direct comparison to the HD800S? I guess so but that's probably very minor differences.
The HD800S has bad quality AND quantity in bass. It has "okish" mids (which are flat up to 1k and recessed from 1k to 3k) and shines in the treble (HA!) and is of course the soundstage king (most big soundstage headphones have this tuning) with perfect imaging. It also has bad dynamics and lacks serious punch and slam.
Have you heard "real" competitors? Around the price of the HD800S? Hifiman Arya? Focal Clear? Audeze LCD-2/X? Any (big) planar? Denon AH-D9200 (since you live in japan) etc...
Of course the HD800(S) beats cans around 150€ lol...
Sorry but i take this whole post with a grain of salt...
 
Last edited:
Jan 2, 2023 at 1:09 PM Post #6 of 49
Hmmm, the listed cans you owned as reference are sadly not that impressive in comparison to the HD800(S).

Excuse me WHAT?

Just no.

Do you mean in direct comparison to the HD800S? I guess so but that's probably very minor differences.
The HD800S has bad quality AND quantity in bass. It has "okish" mids (which are flat up to 1k and recessed from 1k to 3k) and shines in the treble (HA!) and is of course the soundstage king (most big soundstage headphones have this tuning) with perfect imaging. It also has bad dynamics and lacks serious punch and slam.
Have you heard "real" competitors? Around the price of the HD800S? Hifiman Arya? Focal Clear? Audeze LCD-2/X? Any (big) planar? Denon AH-D9200 (since you live in japan) etc...
Of course the HD800(S) beats cans around 150€ lol...
Sorry but i take this whole post with a grain of salt...
I think HD800s bass is great and even better with harmon bass shelf.
 
Jan 2, 2023 at 1:32 PM Post #7 of 49
Nice write-up and glad that you’re happy, but I never found that HD800S to be bass heavy or have forward mids. If fact, I sold them because they didn’t have the level of bass to my liking… even when EQ’ed. Just goes to show that everybody has their own interpretation and preference, which is great.
 
Jan 2, 2023 at 1:33 PM Post #8 of 49
Jan 2, 2023 at 1:50 PM Post #9 of 49
It's alright. Let him enjoy his HD800 and HD800S. No need to compare with other headphones. I've have had Audeze LCD3, LCD4, He1000se but now I kept Susvara and HD800.

I bought my son the HD800S because he was pinching my HD800 for games. :wink: So I have heard both a lot.

I listen to Susvara with this amp but HD800 with it now is insane.

IMG_5610.jpg
 
Jan 2, 2023 at 2:27 PM Post #10 of 49
Hmmm, the listed cans you owned as reference are sadly not that impressive in comparison to the HD800(S).

Excuse me WHAT?

Just no.

Do you mean in direct comparison to the HD800S? I guess so but that's probably very minor differences.
The HD800S has bad quality AND quantity in bass. It has "okish" mids (which are flat up to 1k and recessed from 1k to 3k) and shines in the treble (HA!) and is of course the soundstage king (most big soundstage headphones have this tuning) with perfect imaging. It also has bad dynamics and lacks serious punch and slam.
Have you heard "real" competitors? Around the price of the HD800S? Hifiman Arya? Focal Clear? Audeze LCD-2/X? Any (big) planar? Denon AH-D9200 (since you live in japan) etc...
Of course the HD800(S) beats cans around 150€ lol...
Sorry but i take this whole post with a grain of salt...
Had all the headphones you have mentioned and just bought another pair of HD800S…all the others are gone…and I don’t listen to classical or soundtracks. Mostly singer/songwriter etc.
It’s one of the best out there.
 
Jan 2, 2023 at 10:37 PM Post #11 of 49
Had all the headphones you have mentioned and just bought another pair of HD800S…all the others are gone…and I don’t listen to classical or soundtracks. Mostly singer/songwriter etc.
It’s one of the best out there.
NOICE! interesting that your musical tastes are completely different and you'd still pick an 800! enjoy
 
Last edited:
Jan 2, 2023 at 10:41 PM Post #12 of 49
It's alright. Let him enjoy his HD800 and HD800S. No need to compare with other headphones. I've have had Audeze LCD3, LCD4, He1000se but now I kept Susvara and HD800.

I bought my son the HD800S because he was pinching my HD800 for games. :wink: So I have heard both a lot.

I listen to Susvara with this amp but HD800 with it now is insane.

Holly Guacamolee. Ta-26 feeling really little right now. yep, now i need that. to be fair i paid 500usd for my hd800s and 650 for my hd800. i got fair deals, susvara class headphones will never be within reach. that said i'm a sucker for sound-staging and if anything comes out better than an 800 i'm all ears.
awesome setup man.
 
Last edited:
Jan 2, 2023 at 10:52 PM Post #13 of 49
Hmmm, the listed cans you owned as reference are sadly not that impressive in comparison to the HD800(S).

Excuse me WHAT?

Just no.

Do you mean in direct comparison to the HD800S? I guess so but that's probably very minor differences.
The HD800S has bad quality AND quantity in bass. It has "okish" mids (which are flat up to 1k and recessed from 1k to 3k) and shines in the treble (HA!) and is of course the soundstage king (most big soundstage headphones have this tuning) with perfect imaging. It also has bad dynamics and lacks serious punch and slam.
Have you heard "real" competitors? Around the price of the HD800S? Hifiman Arya? Focal Clear? Audeze LCD-2/X? Any (big) planar? Denon AH-D9200 (since you live in japan) etc...
Of course the HD800(S) beats cans around 150€ lol...
Sorry but i take this whole post with a grain of salt...
as you should sir.
This was meant to be my subjective comparison between the two 800 cans, the 800S may be bass light in comparison to planar magnetic cans, but in direct comparison to my HD800 OG the difference was obvious, not really minor at all, in fact you cant EQ it in or use amps to get one to sound like the other. For Orchestral music and such I go with quality over quantity. so this is a very specific use case and a very specific comparison i agree. People will pay top dollar for expensive Dacs and AMPs and get less of a difference than the HD800 and H800S have between each other. these are two completely different tuning and i would argue to different headphones actually. in the grand scheme of things, there are close enough but that's not what this thread is about and again, i am not Zeos or DMS, i cant listen to everything. Im just a poor salesman in the countryside.

You're right on the money that i went from the entry/mid-fi to an hd800, there is no contest ( although i did own a T1 for a bit), reason is I got my HD800 cans for a really good price, i wouldnt be able to pay a thousand dollar for a headphone in reality. wife would actually kill me i think. never heard the mentioned hi end cans you listed, i read reviews and a sure they sound great. (i thought HD800 was the one to get for classical music specifically but id still like to hear more in the future.) thanks for your comment!
 
Last edited:
Jan 2, 2023 at 11:43 PM Post #14 of 49
Well, that makes the whole thing way more understandable then. Yes, the HD800S is extremely good for classic with its giant soundstage and perfect imaging. When a lot of instruments are playing you can pinpoint them exactly with it. The treble is the best aspect of the HD800S, it has tons of detail. For orchestral music you don't care about dynamics. The Arya v2 (not the Stealth) also has a massive soundstage (~90% of the HD800S), with it the music sounds "huge", like a big wall. With the HD800S every single instrument sounds small, but perfectly placed in the giant room. The Arya v2 enhances the individual sounds in its size, so you lose the perfect imaging a bit (it gets a bit wobbly), but because the soundstage is still massive and the instruments sound tall, it makes for a more impressive listening with a bigger wow factor. That's the only other headphone that i've heard that comes very close in terms of soundstage to the HD800S. You can check out Joshua Valours "HD800S vs Arya" video if you like.
Never say never to any upgrade! You might sell one of the HD800's one time and get a good deal for something else. Sometimes preferences can shift, you experience new music genres that suddenly sound not as good with the old stuff and you're left wondering. You don't have to invest Susvara level of money to get something else that is on par with the HD800S, this headphone is so to say extremely niche with its quirks, it is the best for soundstage, imaging and detail in the treble, but it has bigger flaws in other aspects. That makes it a specialist rather than a generalist, and as i said, classic and orchestral music, yes, that is 100% its strong suit.
I didn't want to hate about it, i also had it for a few months but in the end parted ways with it, since it didn't suite my taste that well for the genres i often listen to (also if you get to TOTL level, the imaging aspect is always top notch, i sometimes miss the soundstage and the wow factor of the Arya v2 though).
 
Last edited:
Jan 2, 2023 at 11:49 PM Post #15 of 49
Well, that makes the whole thing way more understandable then. Yes, the HD800S is extremely good for classic with its giant soundstage and perfect imaging. When a lot of instruments are playing you can pinpoint them exactly with it. The treble is the best aspect of the HD800S, it has tons of detail. For orchestral music you don't care about dynamics. The Arya v2 (not the Stealth) also has a massive soundstage (~90% of the HD800S), with it the music sounds "huge", like a big wall. With the HD800S every single instrument sounds small, but perfectly placed in the giant room. The Arya v2 enhances the individual sounds in its size, so you lose the perfect imaging a bit (it gets a bit wobbly), but because the soundstage is still massive and the instruments sound tall, it makes for a more impressive listening with a bigger wow factor. That's the only other headphone that i've heard that comes very close in terms of soundstage to the HD800S. You can check out Joshua Valours "HD800S vs Arya" video if you like.
Never say never to any upgrade! You might sell one of the HD800's one time and get a good deal for something else. Sometimes preferences can shift, you experience new music genres that suddenly sound not as good with the old stuff and you're left wondering. You don't have to invest Susvara level of money to get something else that is on par with the HD800S, this headphone is so to say extremely niche with its quirks, it is the best for soundstage, imaging and detail in the treble, but it has bigger flaws in other aspects. That makes it a specialist rather than a generalist, and as i said, classic and orchestral music, yes, that is 100% its strong suit.
I didn't want to hate about it, i also had it for a few months but in the end parted ways with it, since it didn't suite my taste that well for the genres i often listen to.
wow thanks! sounds like I need to try an Arya v2 for myself then! I totally understand when you talk about the instruments sounding small in the HD800, having a grander overall presentation sounds like a blast actually. I'm going to keep this as a very interesting option indeed. thank you so much
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top