lin0003
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2013
- Posts
- 5,292
- Likes
- 1,207
the dx50 is made out of plastic right? or at least the mock up ?
SDXC comes in two standards: the current one we are using is the 3.0 version that also define SDHC. With 3.0 standard, SDHC and SDXC have the same pins configuration and power requirement. The difference is, SDHC uses FAT32 for formatting while SDXC uses exFAT. However, FAT32 supports up to 2TB, same as exFAT, so you can format a SDXC card with FAT32 and the SD reader itself should not know the difference. However, exFAT is a Microsoft thing so if you plug a FAT32 formatted SDXC card into a Windows PC, it will always ask you to reformat it back to exFAT - this is Microsoft way of trying to trick people to stick to exFAT. With a compatible card reader however (like the one inside X3), even a Windows PC will allow read/write on FAT32 formatted SDXC card. So in theory, X3 should support up to 2TB of SDXC card, right? Well, not so fast.
At current stage, the reading/writing speed of v3 standard is enough (SD is max'ed around 256GB while microSD is max'ed around 64GB). But once we move toward 1TB and 2TB, the reading/writing speed will likely not be fast enough. To solve this, the version 4.0 will replace the current version 3 standard. With version 4 card, it will requires extra pins and different power requirement. V4 card reader will be backward compatible to V3 card, but the V4 card will not work on V3 reader. So the simple truth is, though iBasso claims the DX50 is future proof, it really isn't - if the future 2TG SDXC card is V4 standard, neither DX50 or X3 will be able to read it. At this point, no one really know when V4 standard will be used, so claiming future compatibility is mostly just a wishful thinking.
Interesting stuff. Seems like a pretty bad gaffe on the part of the Fiio engineers and/or marketing guys though.
I am confused about DX50's claim of "2TB" microSDXC support.
2TB is just the theoretical storage limit of SDXC, assuming that hardware is compatible. Current gen 128GB (and maybe 256GB) SDXC can be formatted to fat32 and used in any current portable device with SD card slot. But there is no guarantee that future SDXC cards will have the same hardware; any change in pin setting or power consumption can easily render current SD slots unusable.
There is nothing misleading AT ALL.
The current microSDXC standard supports up to 2TB cards. Ibassos implementation supports exFAT, so any card following the standard will be supported. This includes 2TB cards which are theoretically possible. Impractical with current transfer speeds, but possible. I, for one, applaud Ibasso for adding exFAT support, unlike the DX100 which tops out at 32gb (unless you format your 64gb cards to FAT).
Are you sure iBasso DX50 supports exFAT? Please provide credible source.
exFAT is just a file system though. We should not assume that pin setting, power consumption and hardware spec will remain the same (remember, the largest commercially available SDXC is currently 256GB -- we are assuming things beyond that -- future 2TB support is just a theoretical assumption without considering any potential hardware change). Those hardware will likely change, in fact, to provide faster processing / transfer speed and make things realistically usable.
I will be really glad though, if iBasso DX50, Fiio X3 / X5 can realistically work with 2TB microSDXC cards (what is the point of a 2TB claim if it is not realistically usable). I may stop my portable upgrade path right there Edit: I will stop this 2TB discussion herein to avoid further distraction or unnecessary arguments.
who needs realistically 2tb of music on the go? i can not imagine how long will it take to listen to 100 gb of music. p.s. i have seen too the 2tb sdxc support on their website. But i think it is more for the marketing purpose. For me usability matters first.