Decided to try the Grado HP2 with a balanced WyWires. At first at the -15. dB setting for the Pulse, it seemed similar. While I can't say I prefer this I decided to push the Infinity to -5.0 dB and it was like night and day. The LC appears to be extremely sensitive to the input. My other amps I have tried have always preferred a lower setting on the output as the felt overdriven but the LC this seems like a requirement. Now I just need to be sure it isn't only the HP2.
In the Geek Pulse Manual it states:
Volume adjustments affect the signals for the headphone output and line outs. When using an external preamp or active speakers, the volume may seem incorrect. A volume of -0.0dB is recommended in this instance.
This would also apply to external amps. So try -0.0 dB and see what that gets you.