I asked tom and feel like asking you also tilpo.
http://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2014/02/13/sam-harris-vs-dan-dennett-on-free-will/
Thoughts mate?
Won't read the actual papers they refer to because of time and lack of real interest (I have a already formed a strong opinion about this).
I'm definitely a determinist, but more fundamentally, I also believe in the inaccessibility of knowledge. An abstract principle that is motivated partially by results of Godel and axiomatic mathematics, Wittgenstein and quantum physics.
I believe all propositions have a definite truth value, but this truth value may not always be determined.
And with that I don't just mean that we don't have the scientific tools to do so -- I mean that at a completely fundamental level it is completely impossible to do so. Our reality is some strict subset of all true propositions and there is no logical/fundamental/physical way to extent in any way outside of this subset. We simply cannot describe what is outside of the bounds of our reality -- and quite possibly many metaphysical questions may have a truth value but it simply lies outside of our reality.
This took some time for me to build up and accept, but when I finally understood this somewhere between 6 to 12 months ago I feel all metaphysical issues have been completely resolved. An answer simply doesn't exist to many issues, and whether or not an issue has a certain truth value is independent of our reality. This principle is extremely effective in solving a wide range of philosophical problem by simply rejecting the importance of the question itself due to it being fundamentally impossible to answer.
Furthermore, as I said, I'm a determinist. I'm also completely against the view that humans are in some way special. I believe we're just a bag of atoms in a physical configuration that leads to what we call life. This notion is perfectly compatible with everything we know from science. But it just leaves one single issue as most people know.
What about free will? I believe there is no such thing. But then what about the feeling of consciousness an individual has? I most certainly feel like I have consciousness and free will.
And this is where the fundamental issue creeps in, with my following answer: this is
fundamentally inexplicable.
We cannot find out or understand the explanation for this phenomenon simply because it lies beyond our reality.
An extremely unsatisfying answer when I first thought of it. But I truly believe that this is the only answer to the issue.