SoundsGood
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2005
- Posts
- 152
- Likes
- 12
Quote:
I only know the 8th from this set, and of all the recordings I have of this symphony, (Chailly, Nagano, Bernstein [Sony and DG DVD], Solti, Stokowski) Bertini's ranks darn near the top. I must say it is a towering achievement, and while I haven't heard the other recordings in the box set, I'm sure the 8th is the best, or one of the best. Everything sounds absolutely right when listening to it; Bertini has some wonderfully judged tempos. The playing is also wonderful, special mention to the horn section, they are very powerful with a large, heroic tone. The vocal soloists are first rate as well, something that somewhat detracts from the otherwise spectacular Nagano recording.
I don't think anyone has nailed the closing pages of this symphony better than Bertini (Nagano comes close). It is slow, grand, and overwhelming in its power. I love it, and you can tell everyone is having a field day with it. The brass are going nuts, the organ is great, everything sounds wonderful. If you like your Mahler 8 ending in the spirit of Bernstein, then this perhaps isn't the ending for you, but I encourage you to hear it anyway. I, however, think Bernstein always rushed to the end of this symphony; though his ending on the DG DVD (which BTW is spectacular and should be seen and heard by everyone) is not so rushed like his Sony performance.
All in all, a spectacular recording of the Eighth. I hadn't listened to it in a while, this thread got it back in my CD player.
Originally Posted by Bunnyears EMI plans to release the complete Bertini Mahler cycle in a "budget" box set on Jan. 10, 2006. Anyone know anything about Bertini's recordings? |
I only know the 8th from this set, and of all the recordings I have of this symphony, (Chailly, Nagano, Bernstein [Sony and DG DVD], Solti, Stokowski) Bertini's ranks darn near the top. I must say it is a towering achievement, and while I haven't heard the other recordings in the box set, I'm sure the 8th is the best, or one of the best. Everything sounds absolutely right when listening to it; Bertini has some wonderfully judged tempos. The playing is also wonderful, special mention to the horn section, they are very powerful with a large, heroic tone. The vocal soloists are first rate as well, something that somewhat detracts from the otherwise spectacular Nagano recording.
I don't think anyone has nailed the closing pages of this symphony better than Bertini (Nagano comes close). It is slow, grand, and overwhelming in its power. I love it, and you can tell everyone is having a field day with it. The brass are going nuts, the organ is great, everything sounds wonderful. If you like your Mahler 8 ending in the spirit of Bernstein, then this perhaps isn't the ending for you, but I encourage you to hear it anyway. I, however, think Bernstein always rushed to the end of this symphony; though his ending on the DG DVD (which BTW is spectacular and should be seen and heard by everyone) is not so rushed like his Sony performance.
All in all, a spectacular recording of the Eighth. I hadn't listened to it in a while, this thread got it back in my CD player.