They're finally done. Here's a comparison, newly foamed pad on the left, my first attempt on the right.
I'm not sure how well it's going to show in the photos, but the pads now look much better to me, almost passable as new ones in the flesh. They came out better than any I've done before, at the very least. With my first attempt the foam was only half the thickness that it needed to be, as I was still working largely on guesses back then, being my very first earpad refoam ever, and I got quite a lot of things wrong. No rear angle on the foam, straight cuts on the end creating a visible seam/gap through the velour, and I'd seated the foam too far back into the velour on the bottom, so that the pleather crept over the seamline; creating a more squared-off bottom shape to the bottom of the pad. Oh, and a thinner needle helps with the stitching too, I wasn't snagging and pulling that super delicate pleather this time.
I took some extra time to massage the foam into the right place, so that the bottom of the foam lined up with the pleather underneath. Took some time to massage the foam into the material full stop, given the extra thickness compared to before.
First impressions. They are certainly more comfortable now, softer, and not so thin and pointy against my head. My sound impressions were confusing at first, but it made sense eventually. I'd decided to pick a different artist and album to listen to this time around, so when I settled in to listen to my minimum half an hour warm-up before doing the sewing, I was surprised that the headphones sounded far more forward to me, with a restricted soundstage, less clear highs and less open altogether.
I didn't remember them sounding like that last night, which is pretty recent, but okay I guess? Were my impressions really that wrong? I could only carry on and see what happened.
Listening again afterwards, I had really hoped that they would open up again and get their usual sound back, but that didn't happen. However, they no longer sounded so aggressively forward, they sounded more like where they ought to be in that regard, and the imaging seemed to improved a bit, with perhaps with just a little smidgen more of that 3D suggestion, but otherwise the cramped and muffled feeling hadn't gone.
The biggest difference turned out to be something I least expected; timbre is now far more realistic and true to life. Acoustic guitar strings and bells are now sounding like they should do, and I grew up with a parent who played guitar all the time, so I reckon I knows what that sound ought to be. Even the vocals though, sounded much better in timbre. Natural vocal timbre is something I had only ever previously noticed with the HD520 I, and had until now assumed it to be a characteristic that was unique to their copper voicecoils. I'd wished the 540's could have that characteristic, so I'm pretty pleased with that outcome.
Wondering what to listen to next, I selected a different album by the same artist, one that I'd listened to last night before I slept, just incase something was different with that album. Well now, isn't that interesting. Not muffled. Clarity is restored. Stage is no longer constricted, and maybe even a little taller than usual. It was a difference in mastering that was throwing everything off.
I hadn't expected that to be such a big factor, but it really goes to show.
On this album, with a far less restricted sound, these sound very nice. That sense of extra depth and layering that I can't quite access, is tantalisingly out of reach, but I can tell that it's
there waiting for a dac that can properly show it off. The improved imaging is a small, but welcome addition alongside that more layered stage, but the timbral accuracy really steals the spotlight: I'm not as good of a romance writer as Sennsay, but I know that this will be right up his street! I can only describe the sound as more inviting because of that added realism.
The only single downside from this weeks tweaking is that it's not taken away the sibilance, but I'm convinced that its a "me" problem at this point, and not the headphones.
I'll need more time to give a more nuanced insight, but I can confidently say that all of this work seems to have paid off. I still think that the dampening foam in the back of the cups would be better off being somewhere between 2-4mm, instead of the 6.3mm that I'm having to use at the moment, I think that'd be enough to give that tiny bit of air and openness back. But otherwise this low density polyurethane upholstery foam seems to be a winner so far