You're certainly having a good time with all the measuring! Just to be clear, are you saying that the large suck-out at 8-10k is a measuring device flaw? It's not something I would like to have in any of my cans, as that is approaching the limits of my hearing and would possibly seriously degrade top end detail, focus and imaging and currently I am not experiencing that, though the No 1 Ref1s are very smooth in that area with near new wang pleathers and Mogami cable.
In saying that, I have been looking at my almost stock 2nd HD540 Ref1s, they have a partly used set of wang pleathers but are otherwise as they came from the factory, complete with the stock cable, which as I have mentioned previously does have some upper mid/lower treble 'exposure' and I have enjoyed countless hours in sheer joy with them. I want to be able to see if I can again find that joy with them as they are and I certainly have, though it's needed a fair bit of playing around with the HDAM and Burson modules in the FrankenZero. The options were the long time favourite Audio-gd Earth HDAM, all full sized discrete components and a Russian ex-military Paper In Oil [PIO] 0.1uF non-polar cap across the power supply pins of the HDAM. Burson recommend the same thing with their modules once run in, 100 hours +, I have not done that with the Vivid V6 as yet, which currently has some 150 hours+ on it. The Vivid V6 is option 2 and the nowhere near-run in Burson Classic V6 is option 3, though it is certainly starting to open out after some 26 hours.
The A-gd HDAM I've had for some 14 years now (I have several of them, including at least two of the Moon versions and a Sun module, all are different sonically, though the Earth is the most neutral and my all time preference). and it was this module in Frankie that has brought me so much musical joy in all of that time, including playing BluRays through it into my TRI TRV-88SE valve amplifier into Triangle Antal EX speakers, stunning results.
No 2 Ref 1s: I actually started with the Burson Vivid V6 in Frankie, since it was already on board. Results were superbly clear, very focused though not as much sound stage height as I'm used to, a little removed from being intimately all-encompassing, a little lacking in sheer bass fullness (unlike with the No 1 Ref1s), yet extremely revealing of recording quality. Very tuneful! I went, "Hmm", and replaced it with the Classic V6. What a difference! Fuller, closer, a little less transparent, top end was good, but more on that in a minute. Good fun, more intimate, though I can hear the grain in the upper mids/lower treble, a coarseness I'm very familiar with, yet I still had fun with this combo. Bass is more mid-bass focused, fuller and less detailed and quite clearly more rolled off in the lower and sub-bass, the Vivid being far more neutral. Top end is good, but no Vivid V6. Playing Richard Thompson's Calgary Cross Live, with it's sparse vocals and cymbal work, balanced with a really live sounding drum kit, shows the grain in the vocals immediately, as with the cymbals, coarser and not as pure as I'm used to with this much played test piece. My favourite version of Pulp's Common People is by William Shatner and Joe Jackson, imbued with so much emotional intent, hints of derision and repressed expression of the middle class society, made even better by the children's chorus it becomes a powerful piece of musical story-telling. I've heard it sound quite ordinary before, with coarse and edgy chorus and compression. Not here and neither with the Classic V6, though the grain is smooth while noticeable. No nasty edges. The chorus has individual voices and space and it has mass, William and Joe's voices are wonderful, with depth and separation. The Classic is great with rock music, especially if you like a bit extra mid-bass punch and fuller vocals. Top end is good, yet without the instant transparency and harmonic details of the Vivid, the speed of transients and what this does to the expression and intent of those playing these instruments.
Out it went and the HDAM went in. Wow! Here we go. Now I have the utterly all-encompassing virtual surround sound that I enjoyed those few years ago, no ear cups or skull apparent, just music in space all through, above and below and in front of my head. It's not quite as focused and pinpoint as the Vivid V6, vocals are more forward than the No 1 Ref1s and while I can hear that grain it's not stopping me from having a great time, really just a coarsening of fine detail. Instantly fine rhythmic timing, my body wants to move immediately, music is alive! Best overall match yet? With the No2 Ref1s, for sheer intimately organic enjoyment, pretty much yes. It's an overall package with the original cable that is a very good match .... unless you like being a little more separated from your music. Bass is more open and extended than the Classic V6, it's free of the confines of ear capsules and this was shown instantly with the very quirky album from Life Without Buildings, especially the last track, Sorrow. A sparsely recorded piece, the bass plays quite gently, a rhythm guitar is RHS and kick drum and cymbals to the left, outside and lower than the LH capsule and has a really solid weighty crack from the skin. The singer, Sue Tompkins voice, partly sings and talks her story, this is no 'normal' piece of music, but man is it telling on how well this music is communicated, or not. In the case of the HDAM, it's brilliant. Bass is too thick for the details of the drum kit with the Classic, the Earth HDAM has me right in the mix, no way to avoid what is being communicated here, kick drum taut, textured and cymbals almost there with the Vivid.
So, all good here right? Well, after two or three days of this, I popped the Vivid V6 back in and was immediately struck by the greater transparency, detail retrieval from top to bottom (without brightness!), image focus and the sheer musical intent of every piece of music played through it. True, a bit less
in the musical event, yet with this set of Ref1s the musical event is revealed in fine clarity, despite the slight peakiness (if a little smoother with the Vivid V6) and grain, less noticeable with some music. The obvious detail retrieval in the top and bottom ends are immediately heard, there is a purity of signal that the others don't quite have, Classic V6 the more so and the HDAM is pretty close to the Vivid, if with a bigger, bolder and more immediate soundfield, plus it is just so much fun to listen to!
I often finish my night's session with a singular piece of music by the West Australian Symphony Orchestra, Rodolpho's Dream, as excerpt from La Boheme. A glorious piece that is both relaxing and expressive of a dream state experience. The Classic blurred the basses and lost some of the resinous bite and ambient detail, top and bottom, smoothed over and a bit 'brown', weirdly. The HDAM was an involving and thoroughly intimate experience, yet with the Vivid V6, here we have the real intent of every played string, the actually
'feeling' of the dream state, instruments sound much more real and alive, ambient space surrounds the musicians and all of this becomes even more so when I plug in the No1 Ref1s! The whole track now becomes a musical masterpiece, that can only be described as 'OMG beautiful!' and 'exquisite'.
I can actually enjoy my No2 Ref1s again! The sheer lack of any compression with the HDAM allows for both relaxing and 'bundle of dancing joy' at the same time. As good as it ever was, no edge, harshness or thin vocals ... unless it's a truly awful recording and I will rarely ever play such a thing (even though, the stock cable will actually thin out vocal density, as such).
A question arose, are my No1 Ref1s
too smooth on top? Certainly there is a much blacker background for even the tiniest of sounds to be seen and heard, the stock steel cable has a noticeably whiter background, more lit up in that upper mid/lower treble area. The Mogami cable is significantly 'quieter' than the original. Does it matter when one is rocking his socks off? Not really! For orchestral and quieter pieces, it can do. I have choices
The Burson Classic V6 will need further time on it, as I have a review to write on it for Burson Audio, I've been significantly delayed by a health crisis for over a month and this is my first more comprehensive writing piece in some time.
A few pics below, I had to cut an opening to fit the HDAM with it's big PIO cap with the lid on ... my kitty likes to jump up there sometimes, and for easy exchanging modules, Vivid V6 is red, Classic is orange. The full sized HDAM is noticeably larger. Most of the major modifications, especially all of the PIO bypass caps are under the main board. The headphone amp is disconnected from all power. It's vastly behind the Magni 3+ in any quality at all.