Quote:
Originally Posted by PFKMan23 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Given that you're looking at the woo from an all in one standpoint, how are you basing your comparison? As an all in one solution? If you're judging from the standpoint of Blackgates and such, then of course. But you don't need to have blackgates and all the super botique options. I would imagine while adding binding posts and such, could get complicated and pricey, you don't have to go all out. I would imagine adding a K1000 jack shouldn't be too pricey.
Moreover, what kind of parts does the Woo use? Does it use a large amount of Blackgates and such as well?
|
My comparision is based on two basic points if the extreme could perform the functions of the woo5 what would it cost and sonics. The first is objective the second subjective.
If the extreme is configured to perform similar functions what would it cost. Well the last FS forum extreme that I saw with speakers taps the seller quoted $2400 as their purchase price. I also have an extreme owner in my neck of the woods who did the black gate caps and plitron and that amp was 2K (it also has been in Denver more than the owners home
) . So I find if you were going to configure them similarly the gap narrows. Its alot how cars were sold in the past a low base price but by the time you got out of the back offices up charges and extras can more than double the price. I do not know the parts configuration for the Woo 5 as I have never owned one and we don't have one in Florida yet, one is on the way to a local (not me).
Sonically I like the extreme, its difficult for amp to sound good with a variety of headphones and the extreme performs well with a breadth of cans. It is not as good for the k1000 as most dedicated amps. It's an amp I recommend for people that have 3+ headphones and also want to be able to listen to their k1000s as well and are not all out with a dedicated k1000 amp. I would not recommend it for people that are seeking a k1000 solution. At the national I had the chance to hear alot of k1000 amps and the 300b amps were up with the best. The extreme while good was not with the upper tier in the performance category. I spent some time at the Woo table at the open of Sunday and I was impressed and thought it performed at a level between the Moth and the Zanden. Both of those amps I place above the extreme sonically.
You are right that if you could restrain your purchase to the base model extreme with nothing added but a 4 pin xlr it would not add significantly to the price, although adding black gate caps seems to add $400 to the price.
They are both solid amps for me if your criteria is best in class sonics with the added features of a great pre/power amp then the Woo is a no brainer.
If you need a jack of all trades headphone amp that performs well with the k1000 but not in the upper tier of k1000 performance than the extreme would be my call. The extreme sounds great with k1000s until you hear a great 300b amp or something like the first watt.
Oh and to be fair the extreme is going to come with decent NOS tubes while the Woo comes with lesser tubes that you may want to upgrade in the future the review below was done primarily with the lesser tubes and seems to be a rave.
here's a link to the Tone magazine review of the Woo
http://www.wooaudio.com/reviews/WA5-...-ToneAudio.pdf