Quote:
Originally Posted by Wodgy /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Not very well, generally. The majority of speakers in the $10,000 and up category don't measure well. They're designed for looks and luxury, not performance. There are exceptions, of course.
|
Which ones in particular? The majority of the expensive speakers I've heard really do sound very good. Diminishing returns is definitely reflected in the progressively poor performance/cost ratios, but everyone involved in this hobby knows that. The only speakers which I listened to and didn't like were the $6k JMLabs Electra 1027Be and the $45k Marten Design Coltranes. I had a good hour with both and couldn't quite like them.
1027 BE: I was literally shocked when told the price because they looked far too nice for a pair of $6k speakers. The similarly priced ProAc D38 sounded much more impressive, but doesn't look nearly as nice (matte wood veneered box
vs curvy, glossy paint/fancy wood). I think I preferred the B&W 803S over them too... Note: the three speakers were auditioned in three completely rooms and setups.
Coltranes: $45k! Yer kindin' me! Maybe it was the room (bare glass walls on one side, glass cabinets on the other) or the unburned-in components (Esoteric X-01Limited, can't remember what amps), but I didn't think much of them at all. They sounded good, but not $45k good. I thought the $25k Sonus Faber Amati (w/ Burmester gear) sounded much better although it was in a much better room.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Duggeh /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Interesting that you should spot that. I deliberately excluded NAIM from my Brit-Fi. My (admittedly limited) experience with NAIM systems has never been favourable to my ears. I've always found their sound to be so aggressive. Although this may have been a speaker issue. As I say. I haven't the luxury of extensive experience. I really should start going to hi-fi shows.
|
Which Naim gear have you listened to? There was one particular combination of Naim/ProAc system (CDX2/XPS2 - NAC282/HiCap/NAPSC - NAP250 - ProAc D80) that I found unlistenable. It was, like you said, bright and aggressive. I think it was poor CDP synergy with the rest of the system. Swapping the CDX2/XP2 for a CD555/PS555 sorted things out
In general, Naim gear aren't that aggressive...