What are the best 'over ear' headphones for portable audio use

Dec 30, 2005 at 6:56 PM Post #16 of 27
Hmm. ok

All things considered, the BeyerDynamic DT-250 80s would probably fit the bill. I use them for my portable setup, and I love them. They are comfy since they are circum-aural, have a low profile (they are small enough to be used portably IMO, and the earcups are flat so they are close to your head). They isolate good enough for on the go city listening. And they have a fairly neutral sound (which is kind of what you described as far as what you would like a pair of headphones to sound like). They appear to be built pretty solid as well. Also, they are the least dorky looking headphones I own. I do have a couple of gripes though - It would be nice if they were foldable. Also, the model I own uses a coiled cord which is a bit too bulky IMO. If memory serves, you can buy a pair with a straight cord, which I think would work much better for portable use.

As far as the cool or stylish factor is concerned, I *think* BeyerDynamic is releasing a new line of headphones soon that will allow you to customize their headphones in many ways (colors, cord type, OHM ratings, etc...).

Yes, there are smaller closed headphones out there that may be a bit more portable (and certainly cost less). But more thank likely they will not quite have the sound quality you are looking for, and may not sound quite as good as the BeyerDynamics. A few that come to mind: Senn HD 201, Sennheiser PXC line of headphones, and the AKG K 26 P.

Yes, there are more expensive closed headphones out there that sound a lot better, but that would come at the expense of a HUGE set of headphones that aren't very portable at all. A few that come to mind: Sony CD3000s and the Sony R10s.

If you truly want the best sound possible in a pair of closed circum-aural headphones for portable use, then look no further than the R10s. You will make quite the bold statement, and achieve maximum 'bling' and heavenly sound quality going this route. For further impact, you could probably get the headband encrusted with diamonds and other such precious gems.
biggrin.gif
Of corse they are freakin' huge, and you would look like a dork wearing a football helmet, so that would be a tradeoff you would have to consider. Nonetheless, they would be the Mercedes of portable closed circum-aural headphones.

Since we are fantasizing, and price is no objet:
If I were rich and headphone size wasn't a consideration, the R10s would be my portable headphone of choice, however I would probably be paranoid to wear them out in a city where I would most likely be asking to get mugged for a $3000+ pair of headphones.

Since the R10s probably isn't a very practicle choice, perhaps the BeyerDynamics could be a very practicle compromise.

Finally, my usual sermon regarding closed headphones:

If you intend on wearing closed headphones out and about, be very careful, because if you aren't you may end up as a nomination on the Darwin Awards website. I know this should be common sense, but you might be surprised...

Good luck.
 
Dec 30, 2005 at 7:47 PM Post #17 of 27
Hmm... It seems there is nothing that fits all of the catagories I stated.

Some do some of it, but nothing does it all..

I just want a pair of closed sytlish and genuinely portable headphones that deliver a truly no compromise audiophile type experience - but that don't look dorky or weird. (I don't want to stand out in a crowd - when you live in the heart of a busy city as I do, it is often best to be as inconspicuous as possible).

Surely I can't be alone in wanting this?

GJ
 
Dec 30, 2005 at 8:13 PM Post #18 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by raid517
Hmm... It seems there is nothing that fits all of the catagories I stated.

Some do some of it, but nothing does it all..



Welcome to Head-Fi. Sorry about your wallet.

I think it can be said of almost all audio equipment, that nothing does everything, but when it comes to portable equipment, there is even more of a tradeoff between portability and sound quality. I came to Head-Fi searching for exactly what you're looking for and haven't found it. Money has always been an object for me, but I have stretched my budget beyond what I would have thought possible only a couple of years ago and still have not been satisfied completely. I have decided that I can't get truly good audiophile sound out of a portable system and have learned to live with compromises and have even gone the other direction and tried to get as minimal as possible, knowing that I might be missing something sound quality wise. After a while I got sick of carrying around amps, dacs, cables, batteries, etc. and switched to a flash player and a set of PXC-250s.

Good luck to you!
 
Dec 30, 2005 at 8:23 PM Post #20 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by raid517
Hmm... It seems there is nothing that fits all of the catagories I stated.

Some do some of it, but nothing does it all..

I just want a pair of closed sytlish and genuinely portable headphones that deliver a truly no compromise audiophile type experience - but that don't look dorky or weird. (I don't want to stand out in a crowd - when you live in the heart of a busy city as I do, it is often best to be as inconspicuous as possible).

Surely I can't be alone in wanting this?

GJ




No sir, you are certainly not alone. Every member of this message board is after the same thing you are after, the 'perfect' headphone for a given situation.

So far in my experience, it appears that such a pair of headphones simply do not exist. The closest I personally have come so far is the Grado HP-2. It seems every single headphone I have owned, or auditioned have some sort of trade off, weather it be sound, comfort, size, amplifier requirements, cable requirements... the list goes on and on. It appears that none of them will ever be perfect. Some come pretty darn close, but there will always be some nit pick or flaw to find.

Your best bet is to continue your search, and select a pair that come closest to suiting your needs. Or... you could create your own headphone company, and possibly make a fortune!
biggrin.gif


With that said, my vote is still for the UE10s. They weigh in at about $1000 price tag, and probably cannot be beat for a high-end closed portable can. They wouldn't look silly at all, are inconspicuous, very protable, and could look 'cool' if you wanted them to. You can select from a myriad of colors, and I beleieve you could even have your name and a custom logo imprinted on them. Hell UE would probably be willing to imbed some diamonds in them at your request.
biggrin.gif
Of corse the compromise would be that they are IEMs, which defeats what you were originally after.
 
Dec 31, 2005 at 12:01 AM Post #21 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by stewtheking
Would this be a good time to remind people of the impending Grado streetstyles?


i always thought this was an ongoing headfi joke... are you serious?
 
Dec 31, 2005 at 12:56 AM Post #23 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by b-sides
i always thought this was an ongoing headfi joke... are you serious?


We saw a prototype of them at a NYC meet May 2004. I would have thought they would have been ready at least for this Christmas season. We'll see if they ever actually launch.
 
Dec 31, 2005 at 5:54 AM Post #24 of 27
i once saw a pic of a homemade one... looked like two sr60 drivers connected through a bent tube. they were even uglier than standard, grdos, if thats possible. those wouldn't be it, would they? bc if they are, god help us all.
 
Dec 31, 2005 at 8:24 AM Post #25 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by erikzen
We saw a prototype of them at a NYC meet May 2004. I would have thought they would have been ready at least for this Christmas season. We'll see if they ever actually launch.


The Grado Street Styles are a White Elephant!
 
Jan 4, 2006 at 8:14 PM Post #26 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by raid517
Hmm... It seems there is nothing that fits all of the catagories I stated.

Some do some of it, but nothing does it all..

I just want a pair of closed sytlish and genuinely portable headphones that deliver a truly no compromise audiophile type experience - but that don't look dorky or weird. (I don't want to stand out in a crowd - when you live in the heart of a busy city as I do, it is often best to be as inconspicuous as possible).

Surely I can't be alone in wanting this?

GJ



Nope, I've started a thread looking for the same thing and after much reading and question asking have come to the same conclusion. Basically that anything that looks acceptable for public use won't deliver a high end sound from a portable unit.

Given the huge popularity of the iPod and other players, the demand for an upper end, low ohm, stylish portable headphone WILL certainly be catered to - just not yet it seems.

For now grab a pair of Senn PX100's (good sound, acceptable looking) for public use and maybe the A900LTD (great sound, mates well with iPods, but hefty) for home use and just wait for more suitable product to be available. That's pretty much my conclusion, though I'll be greatful is someone can steer me towards a better solution.
 
Jan 4, 2006 at 9:12 PM Post #27 of 27
Quote:

Originally Posted by raid517
Hi, if money was no object, what are the best 'over ear' headphones for portable audio use? I like the sound of in ear earphones such as the ER4P's, but sometimes I find the whole hassle of changing the Eartips and so on impractical and annoying. Also in ear eraphones can sometimes be uncomfortable - even if the level of sound isolation is often truly excellent.

So I was curious if there was anything that looked cool, was reasonably fashionable, could be worn over the ear (as opposed to in ear) like the majority of other kinds of headphones, but which was very practical for mobile useage and which also provided a genuinely superior quality sound experience?

Does anything like this even exist?

GJ



Sony MDR-D77 'Eggo', discontinued about 1998. Retail was $229. Check e-bay. They do show up and sell for about $150-200.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top