MachineGunz
100+ Head-Fier
Hi,
A few months ago I asked for recommendations for TOTL headphones and dac + amp.
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/totl-system-suggestions-for-metal-music.916611/
After reading so much online I decided I can't invest so much money without tying the options for myself.
I am flying to Amsterdam to compare as many headphones as I can.
My current system is:
Headphones: Audeze LCD-X
Dac: Schiit Modi 3
AMP: SMSL SP200
I am going in to this in hopes of:
1. Checking if TOTL sound is an acutal substantial improvement over my current system.
2. Finding the best headphones for my tasted of music (Metal and electronic)
3. Learning as much as I can about different headphones, combinations and sound signatures.
Hopefully I will be able to hear every headphone but I plan to listen to the:
Abyss phi TC
Audeze LCD 4
HE 1000 SE
HE Susvara
Focal Utopia
Meze Empyrean
If you have any special requests you want me to do feel free to ask.
Hopefully my experience will help everyone who is in a similar position.
Edit: wow! Where do I even begin.
I went to Headphone Auditions in Amsterdam.
Stefan, the owner is a super nice guy, Extremely knowledgeable.
At first I went to a private audition and in the span of 4 hours I found my headphones. After the first Audition I came by the next two days to continue and try different headphones, dacs and amps. Overall I had about 10 hours of listening.
Honestly I know it's his job but the way he directed me towards the perfect pair still impresses me.
Basically the process of the private audition %was - I listen to a pair of headphones with a song or two, give me feedback and we move to the next headphone.
The main song I listened to on every headphone was: Deaf among the blind by Orden Ogan
If I didn't like how the song sounded I moved to the next headphone.
If I liked certain aspects I tried a few more songs and came to a conclusion.
The headphones were tested on the Fidelice precision DAC, If I used different equipment I will specify it.
I am now going to write my impressions on every headphone by the order I listened to them:
So the first headphone I tried were the HE1, Stefan said he wanted to clear my ears and let me listen to the music as it should sound, In his words: You were used to see the world with a pink sunglasses and now you will use a clear set and see the world as it should look with no coloration.
1. Sennheiser HE 1 -
2. Hifiman Susvara -
3. Focal Utopia -
4. Meze Empyrean -
In the end I tried 14 different headphones on different dacs and amps, The experience was incredible!
A few months ago I asked for recommendations for TOTL headphones and dac + amp.
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/totl-system-suggestions-for-metal-music.916611/
After reading so much online I decided I can't invest so much money without tying the options for myself.
I am flying to Amsterdam to compare as many headphones as I can.
My current system is:
Headphones: Audeze LCD-X
Dac: Schiit Modi 3
AMP: SMSL SP200
I am going in to this in hopes of:
1. Checking if TOTL sound is an acutal substantial improvement over my current system.
2. Finding the best headphones for my tasted of music (Metal and electronic)
3. Learning as much as I can about different headphones, combinations and sound signatures.
Hopefully I will be able to hear every headphone but I plan to listen to the:
Abyss phi TC
Audeze LCD 4
HE 1000 SE
HE Susvara
Focal Utopia
Meze Empyrean
If you have any special requests you want me to do feel free to ask.
Hopefully my experience will help everyone who is in a similar position.
Edit: wow! Where do I even begin.
I went to Headphone Auditions in Amsterdam.
Stefan, the owner is a super nice guy, Extremely knowledgeable.
At first I went to a private audition and in the span of 4 hours I found my headphones. After the first Audition I came by the next two days to continue and try different headphones, dacs and amps. Overall I had about 10 hours of listening.
Honestly I know it's his job but the way he directed me towards the perfect pair still impresses me.
Basically the process of the private audition %was - I listen to a pair of headphones with a song or two, give me feedback and we move to the next headphone.
The main song I listened to on every headphone was: Deaf among the blind by Orden Ogan
If I didn't like how the song sounded I moved to the next headphone.
If I liked certain aspects I tried a few more songs and came to a conclusion.
The headphones were tested on the Fidelice precision DAC, If I used different equipment I will specify it.
I am now going to write my impressions on every headphone by the order I listened to them:
So the first headphone I tried were the HE1, Stefan said he wanted to clear my ears and let me listen to the music as it should sound, In his words: You were used to see the world with a pink sunglasses and now you will use a clear set and see the world as it should look with no coloration.
1. Sennheiser HE 1 -
Sennheiser HE 1 (with their own amp) (Stefan said that a DSP was active to compensate on the lack of bass on electrostatic headphones) -
ahh the Orpheus, In terms of comfort - They are comfortable, very light, good with glasses, but they don't feel like a premium headphone.
I was extremely excited to see them and more excited to try them, I expected and AMAZING experience that will blow me away!
What I actually got was shocking and disappointing: Metal sounds terrible on these headphones.
Now, before you kill me and say I am crazy- I did try different genres on the Orpheus and they were insane but for metal? No.
These are probably the most revealing headphones in the world - They expose every single flaw in the recording, And in metal there are tons of flaws.
If I can describe how they sounded in one word: metallic.
They sounded distant, tiny, metallic, The dialogues sounded unnatural they were too bright and weak, they also were at the back of the recording hiding and sounded unclear.
When I say they sound metallic I mean that they sound like the sounds come through a megaphone made of thin tin that brightens the sound, creates harshness, focuses too much on the treble and as a result everything sounds tiny and too bright.
Deaf among the blind - Orden Ogan - At the beginning there is amazing detail, the growls at the start aren't clear and sound distant.
The bass quantity was a bit low but it was well defined and had nice impact.
At around 1:24 there are cymbals that are playing in both ears - They didn't sound that detailed and did not have a lot of presence.
This trend continues - Overall the sound is bright, tiny and sounds distorted (which is the fault of the recording).
At around 04:07 there are synths that were very detailed with a good presence and body.
At around 04:38 there are very fast kick drums that are not detailed. I am going to be adding the headphones slowly.
Overall - Horrendous, Tons of distortion, brightness, harshness, nice bass impact and detail but completely unbearable do to the extreme exposure and detail of the faults of the recording.
ahh the Orpheus, In terms of comfort - They are comfortable, very light, good with glasses, but they don't feel like a premium headphone.
I was extremely excited to see them and more excited to try them, I expected and AMAZING experience that will blow me away!
What I actually got was shocking and disappointing: Metal sounds terrible on these headphones.
Now, before you kill me and say I am crazy- I did try different genres on the Orpheus and they were insane but for metal? No.
These are probably the most revealing headphones in the world - They expose every single flaw in the recording, And in metal there are tons of flaws.
If I can describe how they sounded in one word: metallic.
They sounded distant, tiny, metallic, The dialogues sounded unnatural they were too bright and weak, they also were at the back of the recording hiding and sounded unclear.
When I say they sound metallic I mean that they sound like the sounds come through a megaphone made of thin tin that brightens the sound, creates harshness, focuses too much on the treble and as a result everything sounds tiny and too bright.
Deaf among the blind - Orden Ogan - At the beginning there is amazing detail, the growls at the start aren't clear and sound distant.
The bass quantity was a bit low but it was well defined and had nice impact.
At around 1:24 there are cymbals that are playing in both ears - They didn't sound that detailed and did not have a lot of presence.
This trend continues - Overall the sound is bright, tiny and sounds distorted (which is the fault of the recording).
At around 04:07 there are synths that were very detailed with a good presence and body.
At around 04:38 there are very fast kick drums that are not detailed. I am going to be adding the headphones slowly.
Overall - Horrendous, Tons of distortion, brightness, harshness, nice bass impact and detail but completely unbearable do to the extreme exposure and detail of the faults of the recording.
Hifiman Susvara
Comfort - light, comfortable, good with glasses, good build quality.
Deaf among the blind - Orden Ogan
I noticed that the Susvara sounded brighter than the HE1.
The growl at the beginning sounded a little bit clearer.
There was clearly less bass impact.
Like the HE1 they also sounded bright, However the dialogue sounded just a bit less distant (which is good).
At 1:24 the cymbals were clearer and more defined than the HE1.
At 02:11 there is a single cymbal at the right side, It sounded very clear on the Susvara (which is good)
The bass impact was still low and didn't change.
At 02:27 the two cymbals going from ear to ear were clearer than the HE1 but still didn't sounded small with not much presence.
The guitar solo at 03:30 wasn't detailed and like the HE1 the Soundstage was small.
The synths at 04:06 had less detail and presence than the HE1, But the difference isn't huge and I still liked it a lot.
The fast kick drums at 04:30 sounded a lot like the HE1 but were a tiny tiny bit less metallic (which is good but still too metallic)
Overall they were similar to the HE1 in sound but they were less detailed so they exposed less mistakes - Therefore they were a bit better than the HE1 but still pretty horrible due to the brightness, harshness, lack of bass impact and body to the sound.
The good:
Light and comfortable
Good with glasses.
Ok detail retrieval.
The bad:
too bright
weak bass impact
they sound thin and light without a sense of power.
Can sound distant and metallic.
Comfort - light, comfortable, good with glasses, good build quality.
Deaf among the blind - Orden Ogan
I noticed that the Susvara sounded brighter than the HE1.
The growl at the beginning sounded a little bit clearer.
There was clearly less bass impact.
Like the HE1 they also sounded bright, However the dialogue sounded just a bit less distant (which is good).
At 1:24 the cymbals were clearer and more defined than the HE1.
At 02:11 there is a single cymbal at the right side, It sounded very clear on the Susvara (which is good)
The bass impact was still low and didn't change.
At 02:27 the two cymbals going from ear to ear were clearer than the HE1 but still didn't sounded small with not much presence.
The guitar solo at 03:30 wasn't detailed and like the HE1 the Soundstage was small.
The synths at 04:06 had less detail and presence than the HE1, But the difference isn't huge and I still liked it a lot.
The fast kick drums at 04:30 sounded a lot like the HE1 but were a tiny tiny bit less metallic (which is good but still too metallic)
Overall they were similar to the HE1 in sound but they were less detailed so they exposed less mistakes - Therefore they were a bit better than the HE1 but still pretty horrible due to the brightness, harshness, lack of bass impact and body to the sound.
The good:
Light and comfortable
Good with glasses.
Ok detail retrieval.
The bad:
too bright
weak bass impact
they sound thin and light without a sense of power.
Can sound distant and metallic.
They are very comfortable and airy.
Good build quality but feel a bit awkward when you hold them.
Low clamp force and good with glasses.
Deaf among the blind
The guitar at the start seems closer, Has more focus on it (which I like!)
The guitar is nicely detailed
The growl isn't that clear but there is good detail and separation in the drums.
The bass impact is nearly nonexistent.
Larger soundstage and overall sense of space.
Better details than the HE1 and the susvara in the drums and guitars, The dialogue doesn't sound far anymore.
The sound is less metallic.
There is a very good balance between the dialogue and the rest of the song (nothing obscures each other).
At 02:17 the snares are clear.
At 02:25 the snares and drums are clear.
At the guitar solo at 03:23 there was a really nice focus on the guitar while the drums were still very detailed.
The separation between the different instruments were very good.
The synths at 04:07 lost a bit of detail but were still clear.
The drums from 04:20 forward had good detail which I really liked.
The fast drums at 04:42 were really unclear and undefined.
If only they had good bass impact they could have been my totl headphone.
The good:
Very comfortable with low clamp force.
good with glasses.
Really really good detail retrieval while keeping good balance between instruments and dialogue.
The bad:
Bass impact is non-existent and hardly felt.
Good build quality but feel a bit awkward when you hold them.
Low clamp force and good with glasses.
Deaf among the blind
The guitar at the start seems closer, Has more focus on it (which I like!)
The guitar is nicely detailed
The growl isn't that clear but there is good detail and separation in the drums.
The bass impact is nearly nonexistent.
Larger soundstage and overall sense of space.
Better details than the HE1 and the susvara in the drums and guitars, The dialogue doesn't sound far anymore.
The sound is less metallic.
There is a very good balance between the dialogue and the rest of the song (nothing obscures each other).
At 02:17 the snares are clear.
At 02:25 the snares and drums are clear.
At the guitar solo at 03:23 there was a really nice focus on the guitar while the drums were still very detailed.
The separation between the different instruments were very good.
The synths at 04:07 lost a bit of detail but were still clear.
The drums from 04:20 forward had good detail which I really liked.
The fast drums at 04:42 were really unclear and undefined.
If only they had good bass impact they could have been my totl headphone.
The good:
Very comfortable with low clamp force.
good with glasses.
Really really good detail retrieval while keeping good balance between instruments and dialogue.
The bad:
Bass impact is non-existent and hardly felt.
In terms of weight they were pretty light.
Good build quality, They feel good in your hands.
The clamp force was higher than the utopia and the previous headphones.
Not the best for glasses.
There is much more bass quantity than the utopia and the susvara and the HE1 however it sounded muddy and not that clear and defined.
There is more impact which I like but like I said the definition is low.
Dialogue was ok (not very metallic and fairly natural), But it wasn't forward and in the back.
The snares at 01:50 are very clear.
the snares at 02:07 are again clear and detailed.
The snares at 02:26 are clear once again.
The drums at 02:34 are quite detailed.
The dialogue is a bit metallic, Again, In terms of detail and cleanliness it's ok, But it's behind the rest of the song and not in the front - It is swallowed by the rest of the song.
They don't sound real - The bass is muddy and bloated and a kind of thick layer on them.
The synths were ok.
At 04:20 the drums had a good sense of body and impact but sounded muddy (like there was some kind of veil on them hiding the definition and the details).
The fast leg drums were still unclear but sounded better than the utopia.
Overall they reminded my my LCD-X, If they had better bass definition they could have been really good, They had good details and nice amount of bass, But the muddiness was too much for me.
The good:
Good build quality, They feel premium.
They have more bass quantity and good bass impact for that extra kick of power.
They are detailed and the highs aren't harsh.
The bad:
High clamp force which is not the best for glasses.
Muddiness in the bass that killed it for me.
Good build quality, They feel good in your hands.
The clamp force was higher than the utopia and the previous headphones.
Not the best for glasses.
There is much more bass quantity than the utopia and the susvara and the HE1 however it sounded muddy and not that clear and defined.
There is more impact which I like but like I said the definition is low.
Dialogue was ok (not very metallic and fairly natural), But it wasn't forward and in the back.
The snares at 01:50 are very clear.
the snares at 02:07 are again clear and detailed.
The snares at 02:26 are clear once again.
The drums at 02:34 are quite detailed.
The dialogue is a bit metallic, Again, In terms of detail and cleanliness it's ok, But it's behind the rest of the song and not in the front - It is swallowed by the rest of the song.
They don't sound real - The bass is muddy and bloated and a kind of thick layer on them.
The synths were ok.
At 04:20 the drums had a good sense of body and impact but sounded muddy (like there was some kind of veil on them hiding the definition and the details).
The fast leg drums were still unclear but sounded better than the utopia.
Overall they reminded my my LCD-X, If they had better bass definition they could have been really good, They had good details and nice amount of bass, But the muddiness was too much for me.
The good:
Good build quality, They feel premium.
They have more bass quantity and good bass impact for that extra kick of power.
They are detailed and the highs aren't harsh.
The bad:
High clamp force which is not the best for glasses.
Muddiness in the bass that killed it for me.
Last edited: