Nice to find another horror fan, Redshifter. You're the only other person I know who I've ever heard mention the "guinea pig" series. (Nope, I won't watch those either - although the "Mermaid" episode might be watchable. I don't know.) I have a real aversion to torture scenes, even when they're in a movie. It's just the worst thing imaginable - torture. I don't know why, but just the idea of it really cut right to the core of being. Maybe that's why the only horror film that ever gave me nightmares was Hellraiser. I had no idea what I was watching when it came on HBO one night. After a half hour I was like: "What the f@#K!" Scared the hell out of me. I honest had nightmares for two days!
My first full blown gory horror film (of course I had seen The Birds when I was eight, and that was a great "horror film") was "The Abominable Dr Phibes"! Same as you! My friend kept walking out and hiding in the bathroom of the movie theatre. That was quite an introduction to gore.
I still think The Exorcist is the scariest horror film of all time. As somebody here said, it's not "scary" but "distrubing" To me, that's what makes it really fightening. It unsettles you and undermines your feeling of being "safe" in this world. What's frighting? A fisherman chasing teen idols with a hook or a child tearing up her vagina with a crucifix. You tell me. Maybe today "scary" means the shock cliche of a corpse falling out of a closet as a synthsesizer batters your ears in Dolby Digital surround sound. Yawn.
__________----- SPOILERS -----__________________!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anyway. I just saw The Ring this week. I bought it on DVD - is it out on DVD in the US yet? I think this was an Academy screener bootleg. Honesty, the first time I sat down to watch it I turned it off after ten minutes. The whole intro with the teenagers talking about the urban legend of the tape left me cold. Do we really need to pay hommage to "Scream" and "I Know What you Did Last Summer"? Those are crap horror films, IMO. That opening underwhelmed me and then when the reporter's son showed up one screen, I was like "And now they're breaking out a Haley Joel Osment 'Sixth Sense' clone!" I got mad and turned off the movie.
TWO DAYS LATER:
Okay, well, I was going to watching the ******* thing, as I did pay for it.
Once I got past the opening I really started enjoying the film, it was a pretty taughtly constructed thriller. Was I scared? Every now and then I felt a little tension, but I really wan't scared....until the last half hour. That's when the horror really started kicking in and the terror built. And then, of course, the well scene and the final tv scene were great! I was absolutely scared! Yes! Sucess!
So, yeah, Redshifter, I definitely think The Ring is a very respectable entry in the horror genre, though I would like to see
"Ringu".
What is a real shame is that Nicole Kidman's "The Others" had the potention of being a classic. What a set up! Great beginning. And then it just died, becoming a laughable mess of a movie. Trim out ten minutes and reshoot a couple scenes and that movie could be great. What a shame!