J.Pocalypse
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2009
- Posts
- 1,220
- Likes
- 31
.
I kinda tuned out when he said that frequencies outside of the range of human hearing affect the sound.
It's not the first time I have heard that, this claim date back to the 60's 70's but has persisted, so it's hard to downright deny that it's possible.
Sure would be easy to straight up prove it, but no one seems to be doing that![]()
You can't prove something doesn't exist. You have to prove that it does.
Have any objectivists watched the video? Does he provide meaningful information or just pseudo-science?
I am being objective, do a quick google, before you risk talking about something you obviously haven't looked in to.
http://jn.physiology.org/content/83/6/3548.full
The Oohashi paper's flaws have been pointed out many times. There's some posts about it in the Sound Science forum somewhere.
No one can say for sure that frequencies above human hearing has no effect what so ever, there is evidence to suggest otherwise.
What evidence? Oohashi doesn't count, you can't use flawed experiments as solid evidence.
When did I claim that it is solid evidence? is is evidence however and something I hope to see more research on in the future.
In another thread I wrote something like "if the benefit of high resolution audio is to reproduce frequencies above 20KHz then no one would benefit".
But I remain open to the possibility that it does, while you refuse to accept anything but your own convictions, and downright disrespect people for thinking differently then you do, even if their experience exceeds your own.
I'm not gonna' have a discussion with you, it won't go anywhere.
I'm looking for solid evidence. Not evidence that suggests IMD within the audible band is audible, which is basically what Oohashi managed.
You're putting words in my mouth. I would readily believe that supersonic frequencies matter if there were evidence to support it. I never once said it was impossible. But the evidence doesn't suggest that it's true.
Why the ad hominem? What was the purpose of that?