Seems like Roon-o-Rama is calming down a bit... there are some DEEPLY disappointed/angry folks still, and I think it’s really interesting... it’s the ’war’ between on one hand the:
- Collectors of FLACS on local storage (who might also have Tidal/Qobuz as a secondary source)
- Who curate & tag carefully,
- Leverage bookmarks & tags & saved focus extensively
- Collect multiple versions (masters and/or bit depths/sample rates),
- Use large monitors / TVs to see many many albums at a time
- Like (or at least are acclimated to) highly information dense representations of their libraries
- Are more likely to use search
VS.
- Collectors who are equally likely to stream as to collect FLACs
- Who use Roon because it takes care of Meta-data for them
- For whom discovery and “wandering around associations to find new music” is a primary use case
- Who are more likely to use mobile (especially phone, but also tablet) as remote interface
- Who may dabble in bookmarks/tagging but it is not a primary use case
- And who want a ”good version” but are less likely to be completists of rips
It’s really tempting to categorize it as the old school vs. the new sk00l, but I’m not sure it breaks cleanly down on age or time with the Roon platform, though I do think it correlates. And I’m not trying to say that there aren’t some pissed off people in the latter camp whose Roon instance was rendered a brick temporarily by the 1.8 upgrade - there were, and so they are sounding like the first camp. But I do think there’s a break coming in the system and how it’s intended to be used, and I think it’s a fascinating moment in audiophile sociology (And i use the word audiophile loosely because there’s a lot of folks who use Roon for extremely discriminating listening on highly tuned systems, and a lot who like it to just sound pretty darn good). I don’t know if it’s generational, but that’s the best way I have to understand it. And I think I know where most Schiit-heads lean between these two camps, but certainly not all.
Anyways, if you are entertained by watching blood sport, and/or are tempted by Roon and want to see some passionate engagement by users, head over to
http://community.Roonlabs.com and grab some popcorn. There is some vitriol flowing in all directions. Not quite a Senate trial, but it’s deeply political and emotional.