musicmind
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2006
- Posts
- 1,480
- Likes
- 19
Hi folks
Seeing the "Rate a movie" thread being so popular and also wanting to get more ideas for good music, other than those in the "what are you listening to now" thread, I thought perhaps we could have a thread where folks post a mini-review/recommendation of an album that they have been enjoying, with comments about the performer, the genre and feel of the album, the performances of the musicians, and also its recording quality. So basically, something in the spirit of LFF's pick of the week, where one writes up a small review that gives real information, and not just a rating like "3 out of 5".
Hopefully it will become a useful resource and not a "postcount boosting" thread
I see the only way to maintain a thread with useful reviews as by having some generic template that can be copied and filled out. Below is a basic template I drafted up, and would like to know if any of you think this idea would be of interest and if you think any other additions to this "template" would make the thread more useful.
EDIT : This post was intended as a call for ideas, but has gone "live" already , so I have change the title of the thread.
Having everything in one thread would make it easier to search (using an artist name or genre) and find music that you will probably like.
If you have anything you think would work well in the template, shoot me a PM. Thanks
Edits :
Added "Language/Nationality"
Added "Best Track"
----
TEMPLATE FOR ALBUM REVIEW
Artist/Band Name :
Album Title : Perhaps also include a small jpg of the album cover.
Year of Recording :
Genre : Pop, Rock, Metal, Jazz, Flamenco, Rap, Classical, Opera, Vocal, Instrumental, World Music etc...
Language/Nationality : If applicable, as in "World Music" genre or music with vocals in a particular language or instruments from a certain country.
Information about the artist/band/recording : Anything you think is noteworthy. The lesser known the artist is, the more relevant this would be. Links to good websites about the artist/band.
Your impressions : Your review, with your impressions and comments about the album, the songs, the performances on it and what you liked/didn't like, the mood of the songs, album...anything you feel like sharing or describing about the album. Feel free.
Best Track : The one track you would most recommend people hear.
Recording Quality : Poor? Audiophile grade? Is it something that you enjoy listening to with your headphones?
Similar albums/artists : Other recommendations that you think will appeal to folks who like this album.
Which headphone/rig you think suits this album : This is head-fi after all
-----
Seeing the "Rate a movie" thread being so popular and also wanting to get more ideas for good music, other than those in the "what are you listening to now" thread, I thought perhaps we could have a thread where folks post a mini-review/recommendation of an album that they have been enjoying, with comments about the performer, the genre and feel of the album, the performances of the musicians, and also its recording quality. So basically, something in the spirit of LFF's pick of the week, where one writes up a small review that gives real information, and not just a rating like "3 out of 5".
Hopefully it will become a useful resource and not a "postcount boosting" thread
I see the only way to maintain a thread with useful reviews as by having some generic template that can be copied and filled out. Below is a basic template I drafted up, and would like to know if any of you think this idea would be of interest and if you think any other additions to this "template" would make the thread more useful.
EDIT : This post was intended as a call for ideas, but has gone "live" already , so I have change the title of the thread.
Having everything in one thread would make it easier to search (using an artist name or genre) and find music that you will probably like.
If you have anything you think would work well in the template, shoot me a PM. Thanks
Edits :
Added "Language/Nationality"
Added "Best Track"
----
TEMPLATE FOR ALBUM REVIEW
Artist/Band Name :
Album Title : Perhaps also include a small jpg of the album cover.
Year of Recording :
Genre : Pop, Rock, Metal, Jazz, Flamenco, Rap, Classical, Opera, Vocal, Instrumental, World Music etc...
Language/Nationality : If applicable, as in "World Music" genre or music with vocals in a particular language or instruments from a certain country.
Information about the artist/band/recording : Anything you think is noteworthy. The lesser known the artist is, the more relevant this would be. Links to good websites about the artist/band.
Your impressions : Your review, with your impressions and comments about the album, the songs, the performances on it and what you liked/didn't like, the mood of the songs, album...anything you feel like sharing or describing about the album. Feel free.
Best Track : The one track you would most recommend people hear.
Recording Quality : Poor? Audiophile grade? Is it something that you enjoy listening to with your headphones?
Similar albums/artists : Other recommendations that you think will appeal to folks who like this album.
Which headphone/rig you think suits this album : This is head-fi after all
-----