Quote:
Originally posted by Russ Arcuri
Robert, it should not drop out or skip at all, if the disc is clean and (relatively) scratch-free. Contact Silicon Salvage and arrange for a replacement. If you're not sure whether your discs are clean or not, use the cleaning method I described here:
|
Russ, I hate to burst your bubble, but the error correction circuitry is not quite up to modern standards, and it doesn't mean the player is bad and needs replaced by Silicon Salvage, it just means you are playing a CD with 10 year old technology, and it isn't likely to be up to today's standards (as error-correction goes anyways).
I have two of the D-25S PCDP's, as well as about 1/2 dozen other PCDP's laying around of varying vintages (everything from a 7 year old Sony car discman, to the Panasonic 470 and 570, to a brand-new-just-imported-from-Japan Sony D-EJ1000). I have done several tests after I noticed a few minor dropouts and clicks on a couple of discs. I compared several discs with obvious problems of one sort or another, playing them in the Sony D-25S and the Panasonic SL-CT570. (Before I go any further, I will say that most, if not all normal discs played just fine in the D-25S, but I picked three different CDs with three different problems to test the error correction circuitry of both players, to see how the D-25S would do on damaged discs)
Test #1: The Lord of the Rings Soundtrack. I purchased this CD new several weeks ago, and it has absolutely no scratches or surface imperfections, but on track 1 (only) there are some problems, I assume burned into the CD itself. On the D-25S, the player will play the track, but there is a soft yet annoying clicking sound for the first 2:40 of the track, getting progressively quieter. On the 570, with no anti-skip, there are about 8 or 10 mild dropouts in the first 40 seconds, then the disc will play fine. With the 10 second or 40 second anti-shock on, there are no audible imperfections. The same CD exhibits varying levels of errors on other CDP's too on the first track. (I did try this same CD with my 2nd D-25S which is in storage, and it responded the same as the one I have been using for two or three weeks.)
Test #2: A compilation CDR that I burned last year that has a tiny piece of the top layer scratched off, about 1.5-2 mm long, and 1 mm at the widest point. The D-25S has severe dropouts for approximately 30 seconds at that point, and is unable to track through that point of the CDR. If I manually skip ahead the 30 seconds, it will play the rest of the CD flawlessly. The Panasonic tracks through the spot with no anti-shock without any audible errors (the Kenwood CD changer in my car skipped for 20-30 seconds as well).
Test#3: A Windham Hill Christmas CD I bought used a year or two ago for a buck. There are many surface scratches all over it, but none very deep. I cleaned the CD thoroughly, but didn't attempt to repair any of the scratches. I played the first 20 seconds of each track to get an idea of how the CD would track with all of the scratches. The Panasonic went through all 12 tracks with nary a hiccup. The Sony D-25S wouldn't even recognize the disc. I tried to play it four different times, waiting as long as three or four minutes, and it still wouldn't play it. On my older Sony it played the first 20 seconds of each song, but had two brief dropouts on different tracks. A 3-4 year old Philips PCDP played through with no audible errors. Addendum: Just as I was preparing to post this this, I decided to give the D-25S one more crack at the Windham Hill CD. After a brief delay, it played the first 20+ seconds of each song without error. I removed the CD, replaced it, and tried to play it again. No go (waited a minute). I'm guessing that there was a scratch in the TOC area that caused the player to not read the CD about 80% of the time.
Basically the point I am trying to make is that the Sony D-25S will track through almost all clean, scratch free discs, but apparently when there are unseen errors (imbedded in the CD data itself) the player may have a few more problems than some modern players. On scratched or damaged discs, the D-25S will usually fare worse than a newer player, like the Panasonic CT570. I still really like my D-25S(s), and the headphone out is one of the best sounding of any portable I've heard, and definitely has the most power of any of my PCDP's, it just isn't as good at reading scratched or damaged discs as my newer players.
Once again, thanks Russ for turning all of us on to this great little CD player, I just wanted to point out one of its limitations since some people are having problems with skipping and/or dropouts.
-Keith