OK, let's see... I only have Bring It On and Split the Difference, and prefer the former. A friend just bought a copy of a New Tide, and while I generally like the prototypical indie rock sound, I miss the alt. country flavour of Bring It On and (arguably) Split the Difference. I mean, part of why I liked Gomez was that they had a distinctive way of fusing indie rock with country music, in a way that didn't make them Wilco clones. Does that make sense? With this new album, that distinctiveness seems to have disappeared. It's just an indie rock album. Sometimes an indie piano rock album even, in the vein of Keane rather than Coldplay. It's a decent indie rock album, but bring the old Gomez back, please and thank you.
Edit: I'll concede that some tracks retain the indie/country fusion, so the album is not totally devoid of this. But still, it's a matter of emphasis.