- Joined
- Jun 26, 2001
- Posts
- 13,469
- Likes
- 1,813
I've spent way TOO much money on headphone gear this month (lol)... but, here is one final review of my latest assets...
I'm only using the X-Cans V2 for this... so, as ever, other peoples views might be massively biased, but... here goes
Grado SR125 and X-Cans V2... (vs Senn HD580 and X-Cans V2)
First off, I must agree with peoples criticisms of Grado comfort... after a couple of hours, your ears really do feel like they've been hacked at by an angle grinder!!
Sound wise though, Completely different story... Even though the SR125s are only 32ohm, there is NO clipping through my X-Cans (unlike with the Sony MDR-CD1700s... Nasty!)...
When I put them on my head for the first time, after being well acquainted with the Sennheiser HD580, the sound seemed... "Yellow"... that might not make any sense, but... the midrange seemed wrong to me, colored... although, allowing my ears to get used to them has DEFINETLY helped... these, even though they are quite low down the Grado range, and even with the fact that I've had 'phones that cost 3 times more... these are my current favorite 'phones
The bass, given the fact that tube amps are generally regarded to be rolled off, is superb... nice and rounded in one breath, and strong and impactful the next... I don't think its overblown, although, its certainly the strongest bass that i've experienced with 'phones... A drum beat sounds like a drum beat... and... (not surprisingly) a bass guitar sounds like a bass guitar
Compare that with the Senns... I guess the impedance is a bad thing here for a start, they are a LOT quieter, the bass has no real impact... exact, definetly, but... you can't "feel emotional" about the bass... its just there... nothing to give you the WOW factor
The midrange... At last, I've found a combination that gives vocals the kind of definition that i like, they sound full bodied, although not to the point of being syrupy... the combination although not supposed to work, does so brilliantly in my opinion... instruments also sound very lifelike in my opinion, although, they can be a bit sharp at times... which I daresay after a couple of hours would jangle your nerves (not to mention any fillings you have!! lol)
The Senns... same again, everything is there, but in a laidback fashion... demanding that you LISTEN, rather than the sound being laid before you
Treble... This is the one area that I'm not quite sure about... The Grados (within this combination... I know that through SS equipment, that they sound bright) seem almost a little dark... this isn't a bad thing neccesarily, but - after listening to the openness of the Senns, you do think "Wheres my treble"... it isn't closed off to extreme... but, definetly enough to notice (unless the Senns are TOO open?!?)
Overall... the Grados are a LOT more forward sounding than the Senns, and are amazingly well suited to pretty much everything, except for classical, where they seem to get congested
The Sennheisers on the other hand... in DIRECT comparison... are way too laid back, making most things sound almost distant, although... Classical is still there forte... I've not heard better 'phones for that genre yet
I'm NOT bad-mouthing the Senns, they are still incredible 'phones... but... in a DIRECT A/B comparison between the two... you do hear the strengths, and weaknesses of both... and, with me liking an upfront presentation to my sound... well... the Grados win it for me
Next step... SR-325 / RS-1...
I'm only using the X-Cans V2 for this... so, as ever, other peoples views might be massively biased, but... here goes
Grado SR125 and X-Cans V2... (vs Senn HD580 and X-Cans V2)
First off, I must agree with peoples criticisms of Grado comfort... after a couple of hours, your ears really do feel like they've been hacked at by an angle grinder!!
Sound wise though, Completely different story... Even though the SR125s are only 32ohm, there is NO clipping through my X-Cans (unlike with the Sony MDR-CD1700s... Nasty!)...
When I put them on my head for the first time, after being well acquainted with the Sennheiser HD580, the sound seemed... "Yellow"... that might not make any sense, but... the midrange seemed wrong to me, colored... although, allowing my ears to get used to them has DEFINETLY helped... these, even though they are quite low down the Grado range, and even with the fact that I've had 'phones that cost 3 times more... these are my current favorite 'phones
The bass, given the fact that tube amps are generally regarded to be rolled off, is superb... nice and rounded in one breath, and strong and impactful the next... I don't think its overblown, although, its certainly the strongest bass that i've experienced with 'phones... A drum beat sounds like a drum beat... and... (not surprisingly) a bass guitar sounds like a bass guitar
Compare that with the Senns... I guess the impedance is a bad thing here for a start, they are a LOT quieter, the bass has no real impact... exact, definetly, but... you can't "feel emotional" about the bass... its just there... nothing to give you the WOW factor
The midrange... At last, I've found a combination that gives vocals the kind of definition that i like, they sound full bodied, although not to the point of being syrupy... the combination although not supposed to work, does so brilliantly in my opinion... instruments also sound very lifelike in my opinion, although, they can be a bit sharp at times... which I daresay after a couple of hours would jangle your nerves (not to mention any fillings you have!! lol)
The Senns... same again, everything is there, but in a laidback fashion... demanding that you LISTEN, rather than the sound being laid before you
Treble... This is the one area that I'm not quite sure about... The Grados (within this combination... I know that through SS equipment, that they sound bright) seem almost a little dark... this isn't a bad thing neccesarily, but - after listening to the openness of the Senns, you do think "Wheres my treble"... it isn't closed off to extreme... but, definetly enough to notice (unless the Senns are TOO open?!?)
Overall... the Grados are a LOT more forward sounding than the Senns, and are amazingly well suited to pretty much everything, except for classical, where they seem to get congested
The Sennheisers on the other hand... in DIRECT comparison... are way too laid back, making most things sound almost distant, although... Classical is still there forte... I've not heard better 'phones for that genre yet
I'm NOT bad-mouthing the Senns, they are still incredible 'phones... but... in a DIRECT A/B comparison between the two... you do hear the strengths, and weaknesses of both... and, with me liking an upfront presentation to my sound... well... the Grados win it for me
Next step... SR-325 / RS-1...