traut
New Head-Fier
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2003
- Posts
- 14
- Likes
- 0
Quote:
I guess it's not the disk drive vs. flash. Flash itself has a limted range of write cycles, too. That's not a problem for typical listening, but it may be a problem when you use it as a mounted external pc volume with a file systems that writes frequently to the same location.
All iPods have the major problem of an internal battery. Typical numbers are 20 % loss within two years. Many devices fail after three years or around 300 charge cycles. Only few reach more than five years with a reasonable remaining capacitance at all.
For battery replacment the mini seems to be better suited than the nano - some people guess that due to nano's battery mount there will hardly be any 3rd party offers. This will leave you with Apple's $59 offer (which is not available worldwide).
I was told that the nano will not even work with a broken battery at a charging or docking station. Any confirmation here? It would be nice to leave the nano to the children for daily listening, using it stationnery instead of leaving them with my hifi CD player...
Originally Posted by Canon My point of view on the matter is that an MP3 player is going through limited write cycles in comparison to a computer hard drive... So honestly the chance of mechanical failure is a lot greater than solid state failure in the application of a portable MP3 player since it is being moved around (I would assume at least). |
I guess it's not the disk drive vs. flash. Flash itself has a limted range of write cycles, too. That's not a problem for typical listening, but it may be a problem when you use it as a mounted external pc volume with a file systems that writes frequently to the same location.
All iPods have the major problem of an internal battery. Typical numbers are 20 % loss within two years. Many devices fail after three years or around 300 charge cycles. Only few reach more than five years with a reasonable remaining capacitance at all.
For battery replacment the mini seems to be better suited than the nano - some people guess that due to nano's battery mount there will hardly be any 3rd party offers. This will leave you with Apple's $59 offer (which is not available worldwide).
I was told that the nano will not even work with a broken battery at a charging or docking station. Any confirmation here? It would be nice to leave the nano to the children for daily listening, using it stationnery instead of leaving them with my hifi CD player...