loaizaprat
New Head-Fier
Have anyone seen any professional reviews for the element S online? I've only seen the one from Moon Audio and there's nothing more apparently.
I was interested to see what kind of sound quality we end up getting with the Element S compared to the competitors.Finally finished my review of the Element S for those interested.
"I'm not saying the Element S beats an $18k Innuos Statement, but I would certainly put it up against their $3.6k Zen mk3, or the $5k Lumin U2, or even the $6k Auralic Aries G2.2, and be confident of a very tough fight - again in terms of SQ only. The Matrix Element S really is that good!"
I was interested to see what kind of sound quality we end up getting with the Element S compared to the competitors.
At one time, I wanted to buy an Element S, but I needed Roon. In my case, the choice was made in favor of Lumin U2, which is 4 times more expensive than Element S.
It's great to know that we now have a worthy alternative in the Element S.
Thank you for your review!
Thanks for sharing the long-awaited review! It is very comprehensive.Finally finished my review of the Element S for those interested. Some of the info is probably already mentioned in my initial post or further down in this thread, but hopefully you'll still learn something new. If not, just enjoy the pictures I guess!
Thanks for sharing the long-awaited review! It is very comprehensive.
The element S is my first dedicated streamer and I thought it was the weakest link on my chain, consisting of Denafrips Pontus II 12th-1 DAC (I2S input), Pass Labs XP12 preamp and XA25 amp powering Focal Sopra 1 speakers. Hearing you compare the element S to entry level options from brands like Aurender, Innuos, Auralic and Lumin makes me doubt if the element S really is the weakest link.
I was thinking that, once the upgrade itch comes, I'd be either getting an Aurender N200 or a HiFi Rose RS130 (more probably the latter as Aurender is not Roon ready).
Do you have any experience with these last two? Do you think they'd be a noticeable upgrade to the element S?
Thank you very much for your comments!Great system you have there! I would consider it very nicely balanced, and don't think the Element S is the weak link at all. If anything I would focus on room treatments, then power conditioning, or even cables if you're into that sort of thing. Maybe you already have those aspects sorted but you didn't mention.
I personally found a worthwhile improvement when using I2S by upgrading from a generic HDMI cable to an AudioQuest Vodka. Then another (very) small step up going from Vodka to the AQ Thunderbird. Massively better return on investment with that first upgrade though, and I imagine there are probably better values to be had using other brands (these are just the ones I had access to).
I quite like Aurender in general and they keep steadily improving over the years. The N200 is probably the sweet spot of the lineup, but I just couldn't do it since I love Roon. Still, I don't think the N200 offers any significant SQ upgrade over the Element S, particularly since you'd lose access to the I2S connection which your DAC prefers imho.
I haven't heard the RS130 yet. Looks nice, but so far I've found the HiFi Rose gear to be sort of "jack of all trades, master of none" type offerings. They do a lot of things well but don't quite excel in any particular area either, at least compared to more specialist devices. Definitely a trade off but if you're using Roon, it seems like you wouldn't be using all the RS130's features anyway. I do love that screen though.
Are you doing DSD upsampling by any chance? I've found that to be beneficial when using the Denefrips DACs.
Thanks for the review - it’s very interesting to receive so much useful information from a real user, and not just a reviewer from YouTubeFinally finished my review of the Element S for those interested.
Thanks for the review - it’s very interesting to receive so much useful information from a real user, and not just a reviewer from YouTube
What do you think about the lack of an input for external clock on the Matrix S?
I'm looking for a transport for my Gustard A26 DAC, Matrix S is one of the candidates, but the lack of input for external clock at 10 Mhz is stopping me from purchasing it - in my system Gustard A26 and audioswitch LHY SW-6 connected to external clock LHY OCK-2 and this explicitly improved the overall sound quality (use Roon and internal streamer of Gustard А26 via LAN)